See all
301 photos

Salvatores Tomato Pies

Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Sun Prairie

Save

9.3^/10

116

ratings

"My new favorite tomato pie (pizza) restaurant in the Madison area."(4 Tips)
"best pizza in the Madison area."(2 Tips)
"Great New York style pizza with amazing local ingredients"(16 Tips)
"yellow oyster mushroom,frisée,bacon"(2 Tips)

28 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
tomato pie
madison area
good for dates
casual
lively
healthy food
good for groups
locally sourced food
good for a quick meal
bacon
parking
crowded
good for special occasions
sweet red peppers
figs
dinner
frisee
half & half
roasted potatoes
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Michele FronheiserJuly 22, 2012
This place is outstanding. I have to say, I think it might be the best pizza in the Madison area. Service was great too. We ordered the special and wasn't disappointed.
TerrenceOctober 28, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Go with the #4! The caramelized shallots and sweet red peppers make an outstanding pizza.. errr.. i mean, tomato pie :)
Kellie LoebOctober 17, 2015
Special, duck confit, roasted potato, yellow oyster mushroom,frisée,bacon and pleasant ridge reserve pizza is THE best pizza i have ever had!
Stephen MundtMarch 13, 2015
My new favorite tomato pie (pizza) restaurant in the Madison area. Is in a strip mall next to a check and loan but don't let that make you drive by. Fantastic food. And they have iron maiden beer!
Sara TetzloffDecember 18, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Now open for lunch at 11 a.m. Tuesday - Friday! I highly recommend Terrence's Favorite - could it be the mayor of Sal's has a pizza named after him!?
Sue LuxApril 24, 2018
Love this place. Tried the Figgy Piggy and it was so good!
Angela W.January 10, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Their $6 lunch special for 2 slices of pizza and a soft drink is a steal!
Jenn BaierDecember 18, 2014
C3PO pizza for me and The Fat Tony for my husband. Awesome that they can do half tomato based and half not. Yum yum.
Bradd PiontekAugust 30, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Great New York style pizza with amazing local ingredients
Jim BruhnMarch 17, 2015
Everything is good there, pizza's are the best!!
Rick ReitenJanuary 19, 2013
make pizza half and half with different flavors...fig and bacon is amazing!
Brian EatDrinkMadison.comJune 19, 2012
Outstanding pizzas--er, tomato pies--here! Worth the trip to Sun Prairie. Here's my review: Read more
JasonNovember 2, 2011
If you are unsure of where to start, just go with the number 1! It's classic, and perfect.
jena sebaldNovember 15, 2014
The pizza here is amazing. Can't recommend it enough!
Phil BerndtApril 16, 2015
Awesome Tomato Pies!!!
Shae MonsterMarch 11, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Pizza was amazing! We will be back!
Samantha HainesNovember 29, 2018
Been here 5+ times
The Tomato Pie was AMAZING❤️
Steve NovoselacNovember 6, 2011
Been here 50+ times
There is a kids play area which keeps the young ones occupied. Very nice
TerrenceMay 19, 2012
Been here 100+ times
shhhhhhhhhh, don't tell them, but they're all kinda my favorite ;)
Bill HoileFebruary 5, 2022
Been here 25+ times
Triple pepperoni pizza
jacqueline KarmaAugust 25, 2014
The fat uncle tony is amazing!
Jennifer ShepardNovember 24, 2011
Good pizza, reheats well. Very professional servers
Jamianne MacKenzieNovember 9, 2011
Amazing pizza!
Dale SuslickJune 6, 2014
Hot day? Park next to sign for shade.
Kellie LoebApril 9, 2015
Red fish tacos
Greg SchulzJanuary 7, 2014
#4. Do it.
TerrenceNovember 10, 2012
Been here 100+ times
No crust left behind!
Steve NovoselacNovember 6, 2011
Been here 50+ times
Seat yourself

301 Photos

Salvatores Tomato Pies

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Salvatores Tomato Pies

Appears on 26 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.