- pizza
- square slice
- lively
- ice cream
- good for groups
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Chefs FeedAugust 3, 2016"The Sicilian is just so addictive. Don’t make the mistake of ordering a 'slice'—they’ll look at you weird." - Chef Nick Anderer Read more
- Anto DigNovember 28, 2020Amazing Sicilian pie! Also, try their vanilla and chocolate swirl soft serves
- Eileen LaunonenSeptember 29, 2015Everything.... Best square on the planet earth!!! That's Sicilian pizza for those of you who don't no
- Jeff ForbesAugust 26, 2014Grab a couple of squares and hang and immerse yourself in a truly Brooklyn establishment.
- Order your slice by its location in the pie - corner, edge, middle. The edge slices are where it's at!
- Neil SanchalaSeptember 15, 2014Get the creamsicle soft serve -- a swirl of vanilla and orange. It's like an Orange Julius in a cone.
- Bruno CarvalhoSeptember 23, 2014The baked clams. God, GET the baked clams! And the artichokes. And the penne alla vodka.
- The sq----air wad ehlse! The spumoni too!
- BauzenJune 9, 2010I usually go for super-thin crust wherever I go to get pizza, but this place makes the best Sicilian-style pies anywhere and it's the only place I enjoy straying from the norm.
- Urban OysterJuly 29, 2011Probably the best value around for a fantastic slice and a beer. A go-to place for a cheap, fun outing in Bensonhurst.
- Julianne ArcarioMarch 16, 2010You HAVE to get Sicilian here.. that's what they're known for! And AMAZING spumoni! (I get mine w/ just chocolate and pistachio - no vanilla b/c its too sweet). BEST PIZZA EVERRR!
- Ben RobinsonDecember 24, 2014Get the famous square pizza. If you don't you'll regret it. 10 out of 10
- ChristinaDecember 30, 2014The best Sicilian pizza I have ever tasted. Cap off the meal with spumoni!
- Nick IntrabartolaJune 24, 2014best square slice in the state! cap off your tasty square with some spumoni!
- New York HabitatDecember 6, 2011Thick crusts slathered with tomato sauce. The hearty slices are in squares and we can assure you one square is never enough!
- Jeffrey RNovember 5, 2013Cool atmosphere niice seating outside. not sure what they hype is all about with the pizza but the ice cream is awesome..
- Never go wrong with getting a square and ending with a pistachio icee!
- You can call ahead night before to freeze a pie and take home on ur flight
- Yuval ZukermanDecember 27, 2018It's really far from humanity and not totally worth traveling for. Decent if you're in the neighborhood.
- Nil SenerMay 17, 2014One word to describe the pizza is "Awesome".... And the calamari is the best I've tried!!!
- Top 5 pizzas in NYC. Very unique "square pie". Not your everyday brick oven pizza.
- Spotted by Locals - city guides by localsAugust 9, 2015
- Cat NooneMay 2, 2015Best pizza I've ever tasted in my life. And I've tasted a lot. Nothing compares.
- cherrie sageJuly 24, 2012Best Pizza Ever. Ate there back in 98', and can't wait to return to NY to try again. They do NOT know how to make Pizza in TN.
- Steven MacklinSeptember 5, 2012Only get the chef's table if you and your party are in the mood for a ton of food.
- Cory McGrathFebruary 1, 2011Def the best sicilian slice I've ever had. The regular slice is decent but when eating here your best bet is the sicilian. Your taste buds will thank you later.
- Samuel ElbazApril 18, 2013Best Pizza in the world! if you don't order a sicilian slice your missing out on life.
- The sicilian/square is the best slice in the US. don't forget to end with a spumoni!
- Travel ChannelNovember 17, 2010The Square is a singular, impressive, culinary achievement. And a kick-ass slice of pie. – Adam Richman, Man v. Food
- Rupert PupkinAugust 18, 2013As everyone knows; it's the greatest pizza in the world. It lives up to the hype.
- Theresa RoldanOctober 2, 2013It's even better than I remembered! The glorious Sicilian slice was superb!
- Melissa AndradeFebruary 5, 2013seriously the best pizza place ever AND you can have spumoni for dessert afterwards! it's heaven
- Rob DaBoomFebruary 13, 2012Step 1: get a square. Step 2: eat it Step 3: repeat. many times. Best tasting pizza in the USA.