
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
The Yankee Rebel Tavern
American · $$$
1493 Aster St (Astor St)
"Very authentic, relaxing. Try one of the pot roast dishes and the root beer float."
The Gate House
American · $$$$
286 Grand Ave (at Grand Hotel)
"Really good food. Keep in mind the island for the most part gets their food all from Sysco or Gordon. It’s the chiefs that make the difference. Try the fish and chips. You’ll thank me."
Seabiscuit Café
American · $$$$
7337 Main St. (btwn Fort & Astor Sts.)
"Great falafel! The sweet potato fries are excellent as well. Some of the best and most reasonably priced food on the island."
Goodfellow's
Wine Bar · $$
1359 Hoban St
"Buffalo chicken flatbread, fully loaded potato soup and sausage tortellini with vodka saucer were amazing. Warm rolls were served with homemade pesto sauce, must try. Best restaurant in the entire MI"
Mary's Bistro Draught House
Pub · $
7463 Main St
"Best (perch) fish and chips!!!!!! The sweet potato fries were great! Drinks also hit the spot!"
Pink Pony
Pub · $$
7221 Main St
"The French Dip, fish tacos, and sweet potato fries are good. I love the scenery."
Mackinac Island Dining Guide for Dummies
Created by Victoria Leonard
21 items • 6 followers
Guide to Mackinac Island's best spots
Created by Willy Beierwaltes
9 items
Guide to Mackinac Island's best spots
Created by Ben Greene
3 items • 1 follower
Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.