Service was great, atmosphere was great, cheesy bread was delicious, but I was very disappointed in the chicken marsala. Also the prices are excellent, they have decent bottles of wine for $10.
Got the Lobster special for September. The pasta had way too much heat. Lobster was cooked perfectly and precracked for easy eating. The antipasto appetizer is recommended here. Waitress was quiet.
They brought back some of the old menu - thank goodness. This place went downhill after the renovation and reopening. Now they need to bring back the garlic knots!
Try the garlic bread knots and meatballs with polenta. Yum! Ignore some of the staff ... competent but not the most friendly! Prices are a bit high too, but the food is good.