See what your friends are saying about The Bagel Mill.
By creating an account you are able to follow friends and experts you trust and see the places they’ve recommended.
orSign up with email
26 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Marc CohenDecember 2, 2016All the bagels are good. I typically get the flat bagels. The iced hazelnut coffee is the best in the area, I'll forfeit my daily Starbucks for their iced coffee any day.Upvote1Downvote
ruth bedoyaAugust 29, 2017Walnut raisin cream cheese, bacon egg cheese, sandwiches like Italian tuna salad. Delicious with great friendly customer serviceUpvoteDownvote
Brittney PotterNovember 25, 2019Plain bagel and low-fat cream cheese! You can easily split as the bagels are thick and filling.UpvoteDownvote
Bagels made fresh every morning! Everything here is good from the cream cheese to the Philly cheese or even the veggie egg white wrap is mad real.Upvote1Downvote
Michael KeoughAugust 3, 2010Everything bagels here are the best in the city. Make sure to get there early because they make them fresh around 4 a.m. each day!UpvoteDownvote
- Not loving the new management. Feels like they bought a bagel store but lack any experience running one. As such, it can get hectic on the weekends.UpvoteDownvote
- Mad real watch out for the lunch time crew from the surrounding schools can get swamped then.UpvoteDownvote
Try the jalapeño creamcheese. Spicy flavor that won't set your mouth on fire... Unless you really can't handle any form of spicy.Upvote1Downvote
Kaitlyn PezikMay 10, 2015not my fave bagel place, but the staff is always friendly and the location is convenientUpvoteDownvote
It's true, the coffee is terrible. If u need coffee, make it a latte. Food is GREATUpvoteDownvote
Bagels here are the best. Highly recommend low fat scallion cream cheeseUpvoteDownvote
Garlic and herb cream cheese is the best!UpvoteDownvote
Good bagels, coffee is terrible. Love the low fat tuna!UpvoteDownvote
NYC HikerMay 11, 2010They aren't taking credit cards at the moment, so don't forget to bring cash (or an ATM card for their ATM)Upvote1Downvote
Quinn HushionNovember 17, 2014Do not ever go here. Ordered food and their Delivery Man screamed at me about my tip not being satisfactory. I have read this is not uncommon on Social Media. DO NOT GO HERE.UpvoteDownvote
While the coffee may be simple, it is delicious...UpvoteDownvote- Bagels with low fat scallion cream cheese are the best. The coffee tastes like folgers and is terrible.Upvote1Downvote
Theo PerthuisAugust 20, 2011Worst bagels and cream cheese in the city. If you want quality, go to Bob's Bagels.UpvoteDownvote
17 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 6:30 AM–7:00 PM
(212) 426-0868
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Lunch
See More
Places inside The Bagel Mill
You might also like
- 8.5
"Best lox & bagel I have ever tasted!"
kW - 8.7
"Always consistently good with fresh, doughy bagels. The service here is also wonderful, which is very rare for any bagel shops on the UES. I will always pop in here on the weekends."
Paige C - 8.9
"Great bagel! Plain with blueberry spread. So. Delicious!"
Lori Chambers
Appears on 16 lists
Created by Philip Harper
63 items • 20 followersCreated by Jumper | RBK ~KLB~
56 items • 23 followers
