Arthur's Tavern
Steakhouse and American Restaurant$$$$
Morris Plains
"famous and get a glass of Mondavi"(2 Tips)
"Best French onion soup ever!!!"(3 Tips)
"Tried the pastrami sandwich, wow!"(2 Tips)
"Awesome burgers but not worth the wait on Friday or Saturday."(8 Tips)
See what your friends are saying about Arthur's Tavern.
By creating an account you are able to follow friends and experts you trust and see the places they’ve recommended.
orSign up with email
74 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- steak
- burgers
- glass of mondavi
- great value
- pickles
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Neil MarucaJune 30, 2016"The Steak" a 24oz Delmonico doesn't disappoint. It's not dry aged, but still delicious & tender with a perfect rub and sear. Not the leanest cut, about 5 oz of fat & connective tissue. Good valueUpvote5Downvote
George HeppelJune 10, 2016Go with the Delmonico. You can't go wrong. Always perfect. But bring an appetite. It's about the size of a brick.Upvote5DownvoteUpvoted Mar 16- Jonathan OrralaApril 27, 2014You can't go wrong with a 24oz "Our House" steak that comes with potatoes Arthur's famous and get a glass of Mondavi while you're at it. Also, the pickles! 😍
Upvote3Downvote 
Carlos CruzJune 30, 201624oz Delmonico is one of the best steaks I've ever had while traveling abroad. Outstanding value for money. I'm a fan of Arthur's tavern!
UpvoteDownvote- Julie AnnMarch 17, 2017Awesome Night out with family.... Steaks for delicious and you always want to go back the next day for more. If in the area... DO NOT MISS!UpvoteDownvote
Kavan LathamSeptember 7, 2015Everything here was awesome, the pickeled cherry pepper is a great addition too. Make sure you get a drink at the bar.. Top notch selectionUpvoteDownvote
ChrystieOctober 29, 2014Great beer selection. Yummy homemade pickles to start. Classic burgers. Reuben looked redonkulous and smothered in cheese. Don't answer the ringing pay phone LOL.UpvoteDownvote
Connie BrownFebruary 9, 2014If you like steak, but the 24 oz. is too big, try the petite sirloin & grilled shrimp combo. Done to perfection.Upvote3Downvote
Russell SiminoffMarch 28, 2023A neighborhood treasure. Good steaks, friendly service, and classy, old school vibe. Low prices for a steakhouse.UpvoteDownvote
Matt KlicsJanuary 25, 2014The French onion soup is one of the best I've ever had... Steaks are amazing too!!
UpvoteDownvote
Ed KApril 14, 2017The QUALITY of the 24oz steak has gone DOWN over time since the 1990s while the PRICE had continued to go UP !!! The especially low-quality fatty and marbled steaks come out once the lights go down.UpvoteDownvote
Gerardo RochaNovember 16, 2014It's great this place, the only bad thing is that you need to wait to be seated out of the place, and with this temperatures... brrr!!UpvoteDownvote- Hey PeopleJuly 21, 2015That steak is the bomb! For dessert get yourself the Chocolate layer cake, that is the best thing ever!!UpvoteDownvote
Lenny GalloDecember 26, 2017You can’t beat their prices on steaks. Excellent quality. Highly recommended.UpvoteDownvote
Jay WadleighApril 1, 2016I usually get a steak, but the pastrami Reuben sandwich was terrific! Can't wait to go back.UpvoteDownvote
JB BlanchardFebruary 29, 2012Bacon-wrapped Scallops with chipotle dipping sauce -- freakin awesome. Seem to be gluten-free too (so far so good). Patron gimlet to wash them down!Upvote3Downvote
Mike CyganAugust 14, 2014Creamed spinach is not to be missed. Not too much cream, lots of good spinach and artichokesUpvoteDownvote- Gregg SalserAugust 7, 2013Steak was huge. 24 oz ribeye was the small one. First time I could not finish a steak. Interesting twist....pickles on every table.UpvoteDownvote
- Awesome burgers but not worth the wait on Friday or Saturday. Also you can't call in a pick up order on Fridays or Saturdays.Upvote1Downvote
Lisa Lisanti-BrittingJuly 20, 2013Anyone that thinks select cuts of meat are good will like it. I can grill a steak from shop rite better. Chewy, fatty, grainy...yuk!!!!UpvoteDownvote
Merrisa🏥February 18, 2013Great steak !! But a Long wait for a table. But the Server Sarah is great !!! Awesome service !!!!UpvoteDownvote
Rick KessellJanuary 4, 2018Just had the Teriyaki Salmon special. Cooked great, very tasty.UpvoteDownvote
Lindsay ListanskiAugust 15, 2012Treat yourself and go for the steak! It's well worth it. Order your side of potatoes crispy or they could be a little mushy.UpvoteDownvote
Kristen AndradaJuly 2, 2017Standard New York Strip steak. Mayne I'll try the Shrimp Scampi next time!UpvoteDownvote
Susan 🌸March 24, 2013Always a great meal. Try the ribs, you will not be disappointed!Upvote1Downvote
MichaelJuly 16, 2015The 24oz Delmonico is amazing, but mine came out medium when I ordered medium rare. Not a deal breaker, but a bit of a concern for a steakhouse.UpvoteDownvote
I have tried the onion soup at almost every restaurant I've ever been to and nothing beats Arthur's.Upvote1Downvote
Norm ClareApril 13, 2010Like steak? Try "Our Steak". Tomatoe and Mozzerella salad is a must! If you're a non-red meat eater try the Tuna salad sandwich. It's all good!Upvote3Downvote
- Best steaks around and you have to have the picklesUpvoteDownvote
Scott HildebrantMay 19, 2013Never been a fan of the potatoes here. C'mon and add regular fries to the menu.Upvote2Downvote
Whenever I want a 'Big' burger this is the best place.UpvoteDownvote
If you haven't had the onion soup yet, be prepared for an amazing experience.Upvote3Downvote
Great Steaks & Potatoes! Pickles in a bucket on the table and try the Cheesecake!Upvote1Downvote
24 Oz Steak is always in ORDER over hereUpvoteDownvote
Poor communication with servers and the operators. Told on the phone we could order steaks to go at the bar, drove all the way there, and they said their policy was no steaks to go. Waste of time.UpvoteDownvote
205 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 3:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Wed, Fri–Sat
- 3:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Thu
- 3:00 PM–10:30 PM
- Sun
- 2:00 PM–9:00 PM
(973) 455-9705
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Arthur's Tavern
- 9.1
"Denville Dairy ice cream is to die for. I recommend the peanut butter flavors and chocolate chip mint. The store is situated in downtown Denville and there are other smaller shops/boutiques around it."
Brittany Greff - 8.2
"Nachos are best value on menu! Huge portion and I order without the cheese."
Matt Sweetwood - 8.7
"Great place. They have everything. If you are trying to find something ask one of the shop from home shoppers. They can find anything. 😃"
Debbie Maulbeck
Appears on 40 lists
Created by JB Blanchard
17 items • 9 followers
Created by Lindsay Gray
27 items • 11 followers
