See all
62 photos

Underground Pizza

Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Financial District, New York

Save

Underground Pizza

6.7^/10

ratings

"Vodka sauce slice is great here."(2 Tips)
"The pepperoni slice was just ok."(2 Tips)
"Awesome pizza and delicious sicilian slices."(12 Tips)
"Must have grandma slice and buffalo chicken...great people!"(2 Tips)

24 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
vodka sauce slice
great value
grandma slices
inexpensive
pepperoni
Sicilian slices
buffalo chicken
basil
mozzarella
lunch
tomatoes
neighborhood
(8 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Andrew BrienzaApril 27, 2018
Vodka sauce slice is great here.
Brian PonceAugust 4, 2017
Been here 5+ times
This is the friendliest pizza joint of many in FiDi and they are on Ritual app so no waiting and you get points! Try anything with chicken.
Duncan PflasterJune 24, 2021
Been here 10+ times
Usually a free fountain drink with 2 slices of pizza
michele jarrettApril 26, 2012
The basil and mozzarella and tomato is great. But the buffalo chicken pizza is amazing!
Liliana ZaragozaDecember 13, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Try the vodka sauce slice or the grandma. Soooo good
Sam GilDecember 11, 2016
The pepperoni slice is 10/10
Paul MiddlekauffJuly 18, 2013
Pepperoni and buffalo chicken were very good
Jackie KMarch 4, 2013
Garlic knots are pretty good and reasonably priced.
Scott M.May 24, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Awesome pizza and delicious sicilian slices.
Chris SandemanJune 4, 2014
Disorganized. They don't have a system, so it's pizza bedlam. I hate paying people to make me do the hard work to get my hands on the pizza I ordered. Pizza is okay at best by NYC standards.
Ann GriffithApril 16, 2010
These guys are GREAT with neighborhood kids! If you're a neighborhood parent introduce your kid. They do a great affordable bday party too!
AlbertoDecember 11, 2015
Good for a quick slice
CorineeDecember 20, 2013
The Grandma was not good, it had a weird taste to it. I couldn't tell if it was the sauce or the cheese that was off. The pepperoni slice was just ok.
Monica StangleFebruary 7, 2020
It’s pizza when ur drunk in FiDi
Sherry BrownAugust 16, 2014
Pizza was awesome
SabrinaSeptember 21, 2010
Been here 10+ times
Must have grandma slice and buffalo chicken...great people!
Sumner MJanuary 30, 2015
The pizza is too heavy and not very good.
Thomas HoladayMarch 30, 2012
Grandma's Pizza by the slice!
Jack HernandezJune 29, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Get the grandma slices, so good
Alan TamNovember 9, 2010
Been here 25+ times
Pizza here is nice and cheesy.
Q - EatsApril 13, 2012
Long lunchtime l
AGMApril 19, 2010
2 slices, coke for $5.50
mystady.com (A-C)December 6, 2010
Meh.
Nicolás IriarteMarch 1, 2013
Las pastas son excelentes! Hablan español!

62 Photos

Underground Pizza

Related Searches

Other places inside 3 Hanover Square

You might also like

Places people like to go after Underground Pizza

Appears on 20 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.