"Just like a meal in Italy it will take 2 hours for dinner."(2 Tips)
"Seafood & pasta SPECIALS"(3 Tips)
"The veal and tenderloin were cooked perfectly."(2 Tips)
"easily drive the 2 hours again for dinner."(2 Tips)
15 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- seafood
- wine
- good for dates
- veal
- dinner
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Suzanne GeorgeJuly 27, 2013The food is amazing and is worth however long it takes to get here. The veal and tenderloin were cooked perfectly. One of the best places I have been too while in WI
Mark BoederMarch 31, 2013The servers are absolutely great...knowledgeable ... been there for years ... truly professional. And of course the food is GREAT. Don't miss the antipasto platter.- Chess ErwinApril 4, 2015Seafood & pasta SPECIALS are usually 'to die for'; tonight was no exception! Seared Halibut filet and a wild Boar rigatoni, respectively! Magnificent!
Dave & Barbara ReinboldAugust 5, 2021The attention by all employees is noticeable and appreciated. The presentation of all entrees and the descriptions offered by waiters/waitresses is over the top and delicious, an experience.- Josh WoodwardNovember 27, 2014I usually hate Italian restaurants, for serving boring canned sauces on reheated noodles. This place is the real deal. Everything is fantastic.
Alexandre MunhozSeptember 25, 2022Great service, good food. Octopus a bit chewy but everything else was good.
Omg. The drinks,the food,the service. Perfect! After travelling through Italy it's the for sure the closest thing in the states!- Shannon BowieMarch 29, 2011Honestly the BEST Italian food I've ever had!!!! The veal chops were to die for!! Will easily drive the 2 hours again for dinner.
Make sure to ask what wine they have open that night. They often open things not on the wine list as a special. Or try one of Wendy's blood orange cosmopolitans!
- Brett SalzerApril 3, 2011Refills are NOT free - even on ice tea. Food is authentic Italian. Just like a meal in Italy it will take 2 hours for dinner. Service was slow.
32 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Trattoria Stefano, an authentic Italian restaurant located in downtown Sheboygan, WI combining all natural and local ingredients with the finest Italian ingredients using classic, authentic recipes we learn from travels through Italy.
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 5:00 PM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 5:00 PM–10:00 PM
(920) 452-8455
Features
Reservations
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
- 8.6
"Love their pizza, great other stuff, too!"
Josh Woodward
- 8.0
"Great food and drink. The antipasti plates put it ahead of other Italian eateries. Awesome ambiance and pleasant weight staff."
Thomas - 7.7
"Food is fantastic! Penne Amore and Chicken Marsala are the best! Very filling and big portions! Must save room for the Tiramisu! It’s divine!"
Antonio Vitale
Places people like to go after Trattoria Stefano
Appears on 7 lists
Created by Clay Konnor
37 items • 3 followers
Created by Nick Manderfield
2 itemsCreated by Shareef Jackson
30 items