Thirsty Pony
Sports Bar, Bowling Alley, and American Restaurant$$$$
Sandusky
"The fried pickles are awesome and burgers are good."(4 Tips)
"Connor is the best, fast and courteous!"(2 Tips)
"Friendly staff, great beer selection, awesome pizza and burgers."(3 Tips)
"Completely recommend the sweet potato fries; they are delicious!"(3 Tips)
36 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- burgers
- fried pickles
- connor
- kitschy
- pizza
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Teagan SkotarczakAugust 17, 2012Completely recommend the sweet potato fries; they are delicious! And Connor is the most courteous, fastest, and friendliest of the waiters! Great bar overall
The best bar food EVER!! Their wings are amazing, drinks are perfection, you can gamble and the kitschy atmosphere rocks! I frickin' love this place.
Brice MaynardJuly 23, 2013I rarely leave a tip, but this place deserves it. The atmosphere is comfortable to start. You can tell the burgers are fresh and handmade. The icing on the cake.. deep fried pickle with a burger.- The potato skins are as gigantic as their wings and cooked to perfection. I also love the spinach dip in bread bowl: browned, bubbly, mmmm!
- Usually a huge menu means a place doesn't do anything well. It's just the opposite here - I've never had a bad meal. Much better value than Cedar Point on-property dining options!
Dillon GrayJanuary 25, 2016This is my favorite place to stop when visiting cedar point. Friendly staff, great beer selection, awesome pizza and burgers.
Jon HighlanderSeptember 29, 2015The bowling is great even for glow blow. Drinks are great when they have specials. Just go easy on the pizza. It will go through you.
Missy BoniAugust 17, 2014Awesome chicken sandwiches and fried pickles! Not so good lobster bisque...I think I had two solid pieces then the rest was cream :( Great beer selection!
- Great place to stop at when you're going to Cedar Point. The fried pickles are awesome and burgers are good.
NicoleMay 14, 2013Ask for mike to be your waiter best service I've ever got so friendly and get the wings there huge!! STEROID CHICKEN!!
Gotta have the blue streak burger! So so good! And the sweet potato fries with the cinnamon and brown sugar dip
Kristen HallMay 31, 2012Service was great, Mike is super friendly. No matter what you order, get the sweet potato fries.
During happy hour u get a dollar back for every drink u get back
John ArgoJuly 17, 2015I manage a bar/restaurant in the Chicago area. The fruit flies are so thick here they made me nauseous. I cancelled my order and left. Will not be back.
115 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(419) 626-6761
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Appears on 10 lists
Created by Michelle L
31 items • 1 followerCreated by Davaron Miller
5 items • 1 followerCreated by Britt Hageman
22 items