The Fresh Market
Grocery Store
Meridian Kessler, Indianapolis
"Awesome fresh meat and seafood...the salmon here rocks."(2 Tips)
"The cheesecakes and dessert selection is amazing."(6 Tips)
"... lots of unique items, organic choices, fresh meat and seafood and friendly staff!"(2 Tips)
"Make a special trip for: coffee, lemon bars, jalapeño pimento cheese"(3 Tips)
34 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- seafood
- desserts
- coffee
- lemon bars
- delis
- (13 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Liz FayeOctober 15, 2016Good for a few speciality items but way too pricey for everyday shopping. Especially when lower cost markets in the area can compete in quality and selection.
Great neighborhood store with lots of unique items, organic choices, fresh meat and seafood and friendly staff!
The high prices are reasonable for the high quality and amazing selection. If you need something special that's not available at Kroger or Marsh, try here.
Dana ParkerAugust 23, 2014The a great place to get real Irish sausage, and an amazing ice cream selection
they have great stuff (back room rosters coffee -yay) ... But can be very a disappointing experience for staples (like...they don't have coffee maker filters! Or regular tomato soup
mmmmm this place ROCKS with yummy food ... the Chocolate Eclairs call my name EVERYDAY ! Try them, you will not be sorry!
Try the margherita pizza if you can snag one. They're next to the deli counter and make a yummy and quick dinner.
If you're tempted to nibble from the bulk buns like I am, buy a pre-weighed container and nibble from it as you shop.
This place is awesome! Their Sockeye Salmon and Salmon Salad are well worth the trip!!
Deana Perkins MitchellJanuary 14, 2012Their prices are really reasonable & lots of organic choices as well
Don't park in the roof when lots of rain has fallen... It a pool.
Good meat and prepared food. Produce is a bit overpriced for the quality.
I forgive them for not having the white nonpareils needed for my recent baking adventures, but only because of the awesomeness of their sourdough bread.
Matt KubalFebruary 20, 2014Food porn. Expensive. Not a place to visit when you are hungry unless you have deep pockets. High quality everything.
Cheryl Dobski HenryJanuary 28, 2018High end product high prices for example I paid $14.74 for 3 acorn squash. Total bill for 2 bags of groceries was $181
Matheau LuersMarch 15, 2012Allow plenty of time. Always a long line in the meat dept and at check out.
their prepared, non-cooked items in the meat/seafood department rock... some have require longer cooking times than instructed...
Love the location, but the service here is a joke
Beware of "specials" price labels. Unless u think a $.01 discount is a deal
At first I was skeptical that TFM was going to be filled with pretentious jerks that loved paying too much for groceries. Not at all! Read more
52 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
The Fresh Market
5415 N College Ave, (at E 54th St.)
Indianapolis, IN 46220
United States
Indianapolis, IN 46220
United States
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 8:00 AM–9:00 PM
(317) 259-9270
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
See More
You might also like
- 8.5
"You can make your own almond or peanut butter here. Chose your nuts and a machine grinds them on the spot. Very inexpensive and fresh!!"
Iris Taflan - 9.0
"If you like Pinot Noir, try the Blue Fin. A personal favorite. And for the price you can't go wrong."
Andy @hust0058 - 8.1
"Always look at Aldi Finds. Last week I bought cute wax melts and wax warmers, much cheaper than I would find at the big box competition."
Stacy Adams
Places people like to go after The Fresh Market
- 8.0
"Great location. Always busy. Wonderful selection."
Andrew Alam - 9.0
"The chili cheese etouffee is always delicious. Large portions and inexpensive!! Cash only, though!"
Sarah - 8.3
"The staff are very helpful. We wanted to buy a nice-ish bottle of gin ($40), but didn't know what to choose. The clerk gave us samples so we could find one we liked. Great service!"
Katie G
Appears on 6 lists
Created by Mikala S
25 items
Created by Julie Newell ☕
6 items • 1 follower
Created by John Torma
13 items
