Stinky Bklyn LLC
(Now Closed)Cheese Store and Gourmet Store
Boerum Hill, Brooklyn
55 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
CITY GRITAugust 9, 2014Whether your looking for the serious fromage low-down or just looking for a great gourmet gift – this is your spot! Don’t leave without a bag of Pretzel Toffee!
It's all about the nibs box in the refrigerated section up front. Cheese, bacon, sausage, prosciutto ends for only $2-$6! Great way to try lots of different things, not to mention picnic-friendly.
Not as large of a selection as Murray’s, but still a wonderful shop with a good assortment of cheeses, charcuterie, bread, jams. The staff is also really nice and helpful.
C BaileyJuly 14, 2020Great selection of cheese and charcuterie. Very knowledgable staff. I’m not local and I can’t wait to visit again and create another amazing cheeseboard.
Veronica RayNovember 26, 2017Love the deals on the "loose ends" near the front. Especially helpful for someone who wants to try out new cheese.
Daniel BarnettDecember 9, 2014Amazing cheeses, love the ice cream selection, freshly baked breads, and everything else that I pick up on the way to the register that I probably shouldn't.
Matt DorvilleAugust 10, 2014Excellent cheese but the beer is good too. Growlers are discounted on Thursday and since it's more expensive that American beer, go then.- JaclynAugust 7, 2016Incredible cheese. Hard goat and Gouda are my faves. Good sandwiches and great place to fill your growler
Excellent craft beer selection and lots of other random little knick knacks you didn't know you needed.
Samantha SchwartzJanuary 17, 2015Amazing selection of craft beer from all over the world. Excellent well curated selection of cheeses and other gourmet sundries.
Hot Bread KitchenJanuary 17, 2012This shop has more than just an endearing name, it also has some of the finest cheese & dried meat selections in Brooklyn. We suggest our Lavash to go along with your next cheese purchase!
Giovanni Bryden RosasMay 2, 2017Amazing collection of meats, cheeses, and specialty goods. Their bread is cheap and delicious.
Go ahead and pick up an $8.00 Mast Brothers Fleur De Sel chocolate bar. Both the taste and the packaging are perfection! Stinky's price tag is about a dollar cheaper than other shops in the area.
The holy trinity of cured meat, stinky cheeses and rarer craft beers. Ask to try before you buy.
José DucósFebruary 13, 2017Thursdays, from 5 to 8, they have a happy hour where you get 20% off filling up a growler of beer.
Thalia KJune 22, 2013The only "ham bar" in Brooklyn. And the first one I've ever seen anywhere for that matter. courtesy of @howaboutwe
I AmosMay 12, 2013There's a lot of costly fancy candy in here, but don't overlook the relatively cheap and very tasty beer+pretzel caramels up at the counter.
Ally MillarNovember 28, 2011The little odds & ends baskets are always worth checking. Small sizes of cheeses and ends of cured meats are great for cooking or a cheap cheese plate.
Peter CucèJanuary 8, 2017They followed us around the store and then accused my friend of stealing a Mast Brothers Chocolate bar. When she showed them her bag, the item was a pack of tissues. I emailed but never heard back.
MarthaFebruary 8, 2015it's not Murray's but for being in Brooklyn, a very nice and good little shop. staff is great.
Jason GelmanJune 13, 2012Amazing cheese selection, but very good sandwiches too. My favorite is the #5 - ham & cheese on pretzel roll bread.
Go when it's slow (and on an empty stomach) and ask for recommendations.
Frugal TravelerJanuary 27, 2010Get Broadbent Country Ham—delish and super-duper-cheap! My recipe: fry a few slices in oil on high heat, add dried hot chilies, then chopped white cabbage (the waxy kind). Cook till soft-ish. Mm! Read more
Daily sandwich menu is a must! Sandwich, bag of chips, iced coffee, done!!
Not exactly sure what you want? The staff provide great recommendations, so ask them
Try any Rogue River Blue....Caveman is always a treat. Also, try the amazing beer & pretzel caramels at counter.
Wayne ParilloApril 6, 2011Amazing cheese and great service. Tell them what u r planning and they always have the right answer no matter the budget.
Eric RichmondFebruary 26, 2012Wow, first place in cobble hill with Tin Mustard! Nothing like it in the city.
Jonathan RobinsonDecember 15, 2012Everything here is delicious. Trust Chris and Erin to steer you right.- eli BICKFORDFebruary 21, 2010they have amazing cheeses so if you go don't just try the everyday cheese try something out of there amazing selection
- I AmosFebruary 16, 2010Get some Casatica di bufala. It's a super-creamy cheese made from buffalo's milk.
148 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Stinky BKLYN is your go-to source for cheese, meat, combo and sandwich platters for that special occasion. We also have awesome party baskets for your own...
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Wed, Sun
- 10:00 AM–8:00 PM
- Thu–Sat
- 10:00 AM–9:00 PM
(718) 596-2873
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Order the Fig and Pig sandwich. Perfect mix of savory and sweet on a fresh baguette."
mb bischoff - 8.1
"Good choice of pasta by good brands also organic and whole whet, spelt etc.Good selection of flours, beans, cheese and olives.I loved the Italian-American atmosphere: it's like being in a movie."
A T - 7.6
"Had to try mozz bagel! Like a mozz salad but in bagel form 😝 fresh mozz made there, limited space...a couple seats indoor and couple outdoor, more for to go than stay in"
Christina Chin
Places people like to go after Stinky Bklyn LLC
- 8.1
"$12 and under table...fantastic! Try the Kato Sauvignon Blanc. Amazing bargain priced wine!"
Kit Ingui - 7.8
"Go early in the day. You'll be sure to snag all of the delicious samples they pass out. My fave: the burrata mozzarella and marinated mushrooms! Also a must-try: turkey-ricotta meatballs"
Anne-Cecile - 9.2
"Love the atmosphere! Great after-date spot to grab a drink and cozy up."
Jessie Rodger
Appears on 153 lists
Created by Dane Kealoha
95 items • 7 followers
Created by Kino
312 items • 8 followers
Created by Slow Food NYC
124 items • 150 followers