South Brooklyn Pizza
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
North Slope, Brooklyn
34 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Chefs FeedAugust 3, 2016"This Margherita pizza is made in two ways: New York-style and Neapolitan. The crust is crispy and soft, the sauce tangy and sweet, the mozzarella delicate" - Chef Matt Rojas Read more
Cole KennedyMarch 9, 2018Good, but not $4 for a margherita slice good. Nice that you can order pizza from next door at Cherry Tree and eat it with your beer though.
Jess NaldoJune 14, 2015I should get a discount for living right upstairs. Value could be better but for a late night option, the basic slices do the job. Classic, margherita, etc. Happy hour specials next door!
Megan DoAugust 13, 2013Order a slice, ask for a side of roasted garlic and then go next door and grab a beer. The guys will bring your slice over to you.
Open super late, but pizza is gourmet high quality with fresh ingredients-unlike other late night joints. Great at any time. No need for toppings, get the classic.
Adrienne CooperApril 8, 2019Omg. The thin grandma slice is a game changer. There's almost as much garlic as cheese. So good.
Michelle WendyAugust 17, 2013The margherita & spinach slices are tasty & satisfying. Unfortunately the small entrance wreaked of vomit & at 12am it was early for that. If you're really famished it won't be (too) off putting.
Barry HottMay 26, 2015Amazing late night pizza spot. A little expensive, but the quality is worth it
Ben RAugust 8, 2014The perfect accompaniment to a 3 am stroll down 4th Avenue. Amazing slices with quality ingredients.
Samantha PaniaguaFebruary 16, 2015Pizza is delicious! A little on the pricier side, but well worth it.
Chuq YangAugust 24, 2014This place has fancier slices than most others around, and they are pricey. But they ate tasty!
#ultrafactsAugust 13, 2012Insider's tip: perform any song by Freddie Mercury in costume, and get a free pie!
LinusNovember 1, 2012Gourmet ingredients, cooked well, and $5 a slice. Know what you are getting into.
💎TMarch 29, 2016Comments about delivery only: took almost 2 hours to arrive and when I opened the box, the pizza was folded over and bunched up in the corner! The delivery guy sucks.
Just opened in Feb - still a small operation; but the pizza is great
Christoffer JakobsenFebruary 4, 2017Pizza is good but $5 for a slice is not right. Trying to rip you off. :(
Jovani zambranoJuly 27, 2011Not worth $4 a slice, the one plus is it's open til 4am if you are stumbling drunk around there
Christine BeMay 13, 2011Standing here for 5 mins with no other customers, guys act like you don't exist. Not worth it. This is NYC, there's better than this.
37 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 3:00 PM–1:30 AM
- Sun
- 2:00 PM–11:00 PM
(718) 399-7770
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after South Brooklyn Pizza
- 8.4
"Amazing list of craft brews. Chill spot on weekend afternoons with a good outdoor space in the back. Free popcorn and they also leave out Old Bay seasoning :)"
Ashley - 8.8
"Made my own loaded fries with all the fancy hot dog condiments. Best $6 I've ever spent in a professional sports game setting."
Lauren Ford
Appears on 50 lists
Created by Canada O'Day
100 items • 46 followers
Created by Andy B.
47 items • 67 followers
Created by Dane B
170 items • 26 followers