South Brooklyn Pizza
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
North Slope, Brooklyn
34 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Chefs FeedAugust 3, 2016"This Margherita pizza is made in two ways: New York-style and Neapolitan. The crust is crispy and soft, the sauce tangy and sweet, the mozzarella delicate" - Chef Matt Rojas Read more
Cole KennedyMarch 9, 2018Good, but not $4 for a margherita slice good. Nice that you can order pizza from next door at Cherry Tree and eat it with your beer though.
Jess NaldoJune 14, 2015I should get a discount for living right upstairs. Value could be better but for a late night option, the basic slices do the job. Classic, margherita, etc. Happy hour specials next door!
Megan DoAugust 13, 2013Order a slice, ask for a side of roasted garlic and then go next door and grab a beer. The guys will bring your slice over to you.
Open super late, but pizza is gourmet high quality with fresh ingredients-unlike other late night joints. Great at any time. No need for toppings, get the classic.
Adrienne CooperApril 8, 2019Omg. The thin grandma slice is a game changer. There's almost as much garlic as cheese. So good.
Michelle WendyAugust 17, 2013The margherita & spinach slices are tasty & satisfying. Unfortunately the small entrance wreaked of vomit & at 12am it was early for that. If you're really famished it won't be (too) off putting.
Barry HottMay 26, 2015Amazing late night pizza spot. A little expensive, but the quality is worth it
Ben RAugust 8, 2014The perfect accompaniment to a 3 am stroll down 4th Avenue. Amazing slices with quality ingredients.
Samantha PaniaguaFebruary 16, 2015Pizza is delicious! A little on the pricier side, but well worth it.
Chuq YangAugust 24, 2014This place has fancier slices than most others around, and they are pricey. But they ate tasty!
#ultrafactsAugust 13, 2012Insider's tip: perform any song by Freddie Mercury in costume, and get a free pie!
LinusNovember 1, 2012Gourmet ingredients, cooked well, and $5 a slice. Know what you are getting into.
💎TMarch 29, 2016Comments about delivery only: took almost 2 hours to arrive and when I opened the box, the pizza was folded over and bunched up in the corner! The delivery guy sucks.
Just opened in Feb - still a small operation; but the pizza is great
Christoffer JakobsenFebruary 4, 2017Pizza is good but $5 for a slice is not right. Trying to rip you off. :(
Jovani zambranoJuly 27, 2011Not worth $4 a slice, the one plus is it's open til 4am if you are stumbling drunk around there
Christine BeMay 13, 2011Standing here for 5 mins with no other customers, guys act like you don't exist. Not worth it. This is NYC, there's better than this.
37 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 3:00 PM–1:30 AM
- Sun
- 2:00 PM–11:00 PM
(718) 399-7770
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer
See More
You might also like
- 9.2
"One of the best meals I’ve had in NYC. Go early, put your name down, grab some drinks at walkable breweries while you wait. Grab a pie but don’t forget the cheese calzone! BYOB no cork fees."
Ryan Campbell - 9.0
"The barbecue chicken pizza is heaven"
Siri 🕶 - 9.1
"Great food, and always worth while specials. Love the Emily pizza! Their burgers tend to go fast!"
Aleah Nichole
Places people like to go after South Brooklyn Pizza
Appears on 50 lists
Created by Canada O'Day
100 items • 46 followers
Created by Andy B.
47 items • 67 followers
Created by Dane B
170 items • 26 followers