Sloppy Tuna
(Now Closed)Bar$$$$
Montauk
49 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
The Corcoran GroupSeptember 13, 2013This place defines the laid back, non-pretentious atmosphere of Montauk - come here to drink during the day or dance the night away during summer weekends. Plenty of outdoor space!
Cyril S.July 12, 2015Good place with a rooftop that have a great view to the sea. They also have some great music and a good view for the sunset !
EdJune 7, 2013Jeannie the bartender is the bomb!! And the mudslides are muddy and delicious. The food's terrific and not crazy expensive. Great space, great people. Cripes! Get off your ass and get over here.
Brian McGSeptember 3, 2014Try the Arnold Palmer cocktail while enjoying the view of the beach & ocean. Good spot either during the day Saturday & Sunday or Friday & Saturday nights
Jackie MucilliJuly 7, 2015This place is awesome. Be sure to head to the second floor for a nice view of the beach! Great dancing downstairs.
@sloaneJune 16, 2012You're not here for the food, so don't read through tips thinking you're going to glean some magical wisdom on what to get. Just order whatever, get a drink, sit back and enjoy.
Amanda JabesAugust 28, 2014During the day it's a whole other experience. Live music, drinks, and sunshine.
Damian BayonaJuly 25, 2015Corn hole and cocktails. Go during the day or at night. Gets sloppy (obvs)
Jeffrey RAugust 14, 2013Fish was good but I think everything was over priced. Great view, great atmosphere, cool servers. 7.00 beers
Gets a bad rap, well designed outdoor bar, good sound system. A little older crowd re-living their frat days.- jared zlotnickAugust 31, 2011Get classy upstairs with a view of the ocean. Downstairs is all about The End - 6 shots on a surfboard.
Meg FarmerOctober 6, 2014Sloppy is definitely the right word for this place. Good location, crowd leaves a lot to be desired. Just drink at the pool or on the beach.
Jennifer TerrySeptember 3, 2011If you meant to the Jersey Shore and somehow ended up Montauk this is your place. All Bon Jovi. All the time.
Diplomatico RumJuly 9, 2012Hangover Helper Brunch on Saturdays and Sundays are an awesome way to recover from the night before.
SetonAugust 8, 2014Complete bullshit. $11.00 for one and a half shots of vodka in a redbull vodka mixie. Not trying to get hyper at a bar. Drinks are supposed to get you drunk... Especially for eleven bucks
Kelly KaiAugust 13, 2011Wow. I'm sure this place could be about 100 times better if the bouncers were not such rude assholes. #lookhotoryouwontgetin
428 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- Midnight–4:00 AM
- Noon–Midnight
- Sat–Sun
- Midnight–4:00 AM
- 10:00 AM–Midnight
(631) 647-8000
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
TouchTunes Jukebox
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
Places people like to go after Sloppy Tuna
- 9.0
"Clean, relaxing, quiet, upscale atmosphere. You. Can grill and bonfire after 7pm."
Natalie - 8.0
"Probably some of the best food I've had in Montauk! No frills, casual atmosphere. Amazing Spicy Tuna Tartare and grilled shrimp Caesar salad. Also try their jalapeño margarita 💗✌🏼️"
Nikki 🌺 - 7.4
"The food is moderately priced and SO so good. (Steak sandwich and the seared tuna are great!) And I agree with Camilla - keep the chocolate volcano for yourself! Amazing!"
Warszawa
Appears on 141 lists
Created by The Corcoran Group
22 items • 28 followers
Three Jane's Guide to The Hamptons
Created by Katie Schloss
24 items • 15 followers
Created by Andrea Barrezueta
53 items • 22 followers