Sibby's Cupcakery

Cupcake Shop$$$$

Downtown San Mateo, San Mateo

Save

Sibby's Cupcakery

7.9^/10

ratings

"Grandma Tea Cake, chocolate cake w/ creamcheese frosting..."(2 Tips)
"Red velvet cupcake with amazing frosted cream cheese topping 😍"(2 Tips)

9 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Sort:

Karina NJune 30, 2021
My favorite place for cupcakes, without a storefront. You can only get extras they made for the day, selection on mini or regular size. Always delicious and beautiful! Classic flavor: grandma tea cake
Serious EatsSeptember 27, 2011
Grandma Tea Cake, chocolate cake w/ creamcheese frosting inside and chocolate fudge Snickerdoodle, cinnamon-sugar cake w/ creamcheese frosting Confetti Surprise, vanilla cake w/ creamcheese frosting. Read more
Karina NApril 23, 2018
Red velvet cupcake with amazing frosted cream cheese topping 😍
Matt FoleyMay 27, 2010
Go after 12 and grab a la carte extras leftover from the morning orders. Always a surprise on what is available.
Gloria Kobow-GarnerJuly 13, 2010
Been here 10+ times
Try the red velvet cupcakes! They are divine! There's no store front, and it's bake to order...so get there at 1:30-2:00pm for extras!!
Dave HoffmanJuly 11, 2020
Been here 50+ times
Delicious chocolate cupcakes!
allisonJune 1, 2015
Yummy cupcakes!
Rachel LOctober 24, 2010
Everyone is doing the cupcake thing these days but Sibby's is truly great!!!
Rhia R.October 27, 2011
Latte Love and Lemon Drop. NOM

29 Photos