Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Sarabeth's East
(Now Closed)Breakfast Spot, American Restaurant, and Bakery$$$$
Carnegie Hill, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Eater and Village Voice
121 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Always crowded for brunch even weekdays, but worth waiting for a table. They do phenomenal egg dishes, and a classic type of french toast. One of the great places to come near museum mile.
Batzul GerelsaikhanNovember 14, 2015Had the best Salmon Eggs Benedict here. Waiting 25min for a table was totally worth it. Small and cozy place in the Upper East Side
Nisa GOctober 16, 2014Great for brunch, and calmer during weekdays, you can pop up without reservation. Try the home special bloody mary, and any of the egg plates. You won't regret.
Nelly TejedaOctober 11, 2017The very best place to have breakfast on the area! They have several stores you gotta try the pancakes!
Village VoiceJune 3, 2013Avoid the Sunday brunch crowd and come on a weekday to enjoy the fresh, buttery scones, herb omelets and the berry-topped lemon ricotta pancakes. Our stomachs are growling just thinking about it...
John McDermottSeptember 16, 2014This place has the most perfectly cooked eggs I have ever tried. I have been thinking about my scrambled eggs with salmon for three days now.
Carly HeitlingerFebruary 11, 2015Hands down one of the most delicious brunches out there. The bacon is incredible! If it's warm out, the iced coffee is too good.
Monica BOctober 9, 2013The lemon-ricotta pancakes are an unexpected but delicious treat....almost like dessert for breakfast! Very busy on weekends so call ahead...lots of upper Eastsiders and celebs nosh here
Paige CDecember 5, 2015Can't go wrong with anything on this menu! Just be sure to arrive early to put your name down for brunch! Usually a 30 min-1 hour wait!
Glamazon DiariesNovember 11, 2012Make reservations ahead of time and dress well for brunch. Brooke Shield's and her family have been spotted there on occasion for Saturday brunch. The seafood frittata is to die for.
Everything was amazing! Crisp potato waffle was perfectly savory and sweet and the chicken sausage was divine!
Nancy VerlyMay 5, 2012Anything you get here is AMAZING! The eggs benedict are phenomenal as is the French toast!!!! Try this place! So popular! You might think there is a log wait, but the tables turn over quickly
AlexDecember 8, 2014Your place if you are in upper east side and want top quality eggs benedict, pancakes, omelettes... Delicious. Classy & classic atmosphere. Expensive but worthy!
Mike FriedlichMay 24, 2019Fantastic spot near museum mile. Fish and chips were great, and eggs with muffin were also tremendous. Service was outstanding.
Dilara CumhurOctober 1, 2016Amazing boozy brunch, not casual, more like a Serena VDW would go on a Saturday brunch. Hello uppereast siders, beware the families and dates.
Aubrie AhmadpourJanuary 11, 2020Great place for breakfast and it’s a wonderful spot if you have family in town. I don’t usually love pancakes but Sarabeth’s gets it right.
Everyone is obsessed with brunch, but lunch and dinner are solid, too. Tomato soup always a fave at any meal!
Hasan MertJuly 6, 2015Egg benedicts and omlette with spinach were really delicious. We liked the ambiance.
Pavithra MohanJune 12, 2013Lemon ricotta pancakes are fab. Dine here in fine Blair Waldorf style: it's an adorable NYC haunt!
CorinneJune 1, 2013Crisp Potato Waffle with chicken sausage + apple butter + sour cream. Yes, I know the sour cream sounds crazy but it all works so well together. Sweet & Savory
Chantae VetriceMarch 23, 2014The Lemon Ricotta pancakes...OUT OF THIS WORLD!!!! You must try them! 😋😋👍
Madhawi GMarch 8, 2015The brunch is delicious, but come back for dinner! The restaurant is super cosy but not too crowded.
Katie SlaughterMarch 18, 2015I tried the Lemon ricotta pancakes as well as the spinach & goat cheese omelette; both were amazing!!- JosetteJune 10, 2015The best tomato soup in the world. Amazing homemade EnglIsh muffins. Great egg dishes all day.
Christine WeiSeptember 5, 2011Like everyone else says, amazingly fluffy eggs. Great jam and pastries, obviously. In the summer, get the pitcher of passion iced Harney & Sons tea. Read more
RL MaraSeptember 13, 2011Be sure to bring home their tasty jams~like homemade. Love the salmon eggs benedict and farmer's omelette ~They have the best scones outside of the U.K.
StyleiteJuly 5, 2011Yes, yes, this is where the famous jams and pastries got their start. Which makes it the perfect place for the perfect Sunday morning (okay, afternoon) brunch.
Jinnie LNovember 15, 2014first time trying this location :) I had a huge spinach & gruyere omelet n delicious bloody mary! yumyum~
Bitches Who BrunchOctober 16, 2015The Bitches Say: A+ Worth the wait to try this New York brunch staple. Read more
Kathryn PhillipsJanuary 28, 2016Excellent brunch. The scones and French toast are great! Wonderful service.
Monti BraySeptember 30, 2014Eggs are so fluffy and delicious. Get something with preserves, aka jam. Yummy!
- Amanda KellyFebruary 20, 2015Great baked goods! Be sure to check out the ambiance with their virtual tour. Read more
Kelly ScottNovember 11, 2012Amaze balls Bloody Mary's come with a heap of pickled veggies on top - ask for it extra spicy!
Gellie ChayaNovember 16, 2014The peach and blood orange mimosa is amazing and uses actual champagne.
Haib BOctober 3, 2011Lemon ricotta pancakes are amazing! Get a stack and share the spinach and goat cheese omlette with someone and you're set!
383 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
We proudly serve Breakfast...Lunch...Brunch...Tea...&...Dinner!
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 8:00 AM–10:30 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 8:00 AM–10:00 PM
(212) 410-7335
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.8
"A mix of unexpected art, books joyously scattered gives you a different view from each chair. Good for breakfast, a late bite (they close 2am) and work."
Gilberto A - 6.8
"Get the table outside for a nice view of the city. It's also less noisy. Food is pretty good and a nice mix crowd ."
Trendy Danie - 6.0
"Great place to grab food when weighting for a train. Tasty build your own pasta. Very large beers."
Gabriel Hayes
Places people like to go after Sarabeth's East
- 9.5
"Incredible museum. I could spend days in there. Loved the medieval room but it was all great."
hello_emily - 8.7
"The architecture is awesome, and the exhibits are fascinating. Visited in March 1998, when Art Honor Society @ WHS had their field trip. It was the perfect day, especially for me when I was just 15!"
Sarah Nelson - 9.7
"Love my park. I've been taking 6 mile walks around Central Park 3 times a week. Sheep's Meadow is a great place to hang out for a picnic. Tavern on the Green is an awesome spot to grab a drink."
Leigh Ann
Appears on 500 lists
8 Best Upper East Side Restaurants 2013
Created by Village Voice
8 items • 134 followers
Created by Belinda Storey
157 items • 34 followers
25 Terrific Places for Breakfast in Manhattan
Created by Eater
25 items • 90 followers