Original Bay Goodman
(Now Closed)Pizzeria$$$$
Browncroft, Rochester
13 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Brian MooreMarch 6, 2018Pizza is a little small (Xlarge is only 16”) but oh so good. Not dry like some local places and lots of flavor. It is very seasoned and a little spicy, which I love.
ClaireMarch 10, 2015The pizza is decent but not at all the best in the area. It's always ready for pick up on time which is appreciated. Friendly service as well
Tom CometMarch 2, 2018The pizza is really good IF you like a sturdy crust. It’s very thick and well-baked. Delivery has had issues tho, several times I’ve received missing items or wrong toppings.
Tracy BrownMarch 4, 2014Take time to download the Flip app they are using here. You can scan to win food and they also have coupons. Just redeemed a $5 one on a pizza!
Really good pie here - spicy sausage, cup & char pepperoni, thinner crust than a lot of other places.
Jesse GothamJanuary 28, 2011If you're a regular patron, and you're nice to the staff, they'll give you small extras for free (sometimes even slices!).
Jennifer CisneyJanuary 24, 2010Be sure to try "Our Famous Deluxe" - pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers and spanish onions! Read more
23 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Original Bay Goodman
620 N Winton Rd (at Browncroft Blvd.)
Rochester, NY 14609
United States
Rochester, NY 14609
United States
Since 1955, Original Bay Goodman has been and continues to be Rochester’s place for pizza, subs, wings and more. We offer dine in, take out, and delivery.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 10:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 10:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(585) 288-0730
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Original Bay Goodman
Appears on 7 lists
Created by Rich B
17 items • 9 followersCreated by Jennifer Cisney
27 items • 9 followers