"Great pizza, friendly service, and reasonable prices."(17 Tips)
"Pizza and extra crispy sweet bbq wings are the best"(3 Tips)
17 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- slice of cheese
- lunch specials
- great value
- sweet BBQ
- (8 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Brittany Maquet-LambertJuly 31, 2016Haven't had pizza yet (it's my first time here), but the dinner portions are very generous for the price! And it was delicious! The table next to us got pizza and that looked great too.
Rebekah JanitzSeptember 11, 2014Best pizza in the Cooperstown area, as a local I've had every pizza this town offers without a doubt the best pizza with the best prices, great bang for your buck and the taste buds too ;)
Benjamin HOctober 3, 2013Their phone number is 547-2930. What a great phone number. I love that it can be easily remembered. 29 then 30. Great phone number New York Pizzeria has. I like to sit on the porch.
Bob St ClaireMay 1, 2021If you think this is anything close to NY pizza, you haven’t had NY pizza. Think Pizza Hut at this place. Mortifying.
- Their number is 547-2930. Great pizza, friendly service, and reasonable prices. Get the lunch special: two slices of cheese and a soda for $4.
Randy NyceNovember 27, 2011New York City curt attitude and slow service. We called ahead for takeout and were told our order would be ready in 30 minutes. 50 minutes later, we're still here.
15 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
New York Pizzeria is your premier, authentic New York style pizzeria! For low prices and high quality, come grab a slice at New York Pizzeria!
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:30 PM
(607) 547-2930
Features
Reservations
No
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 6.0
"Cold beer on tap, real NY pizza. Great prices, what's not to like?"
Rob Bennett - 8.1
"Try the salmon you wont be disappointed. I left feeling full, no room for desert. My bf had the pasta w/red sauce and meatballs and loved it. Price was great for real food in a tournament town."
J Knaust - 7.6
"Dined here twice this week. I really enjoyed the Pasta Primavera and the Linguine with baby clams. Both servers were excellent."
C M
Places people like to go after New York Pizzeria
- 9.3
"Visited 10+ years ago and finally was able to come again... so much amazing knowledge and incredible artifacts to read and view - not many interactives tho!!! Whole town is all baseball, loved it!!"
Andrew C - 8.2
"Bring sunscreen and a hat because most seats are in the sun."
loran jonak - 6.3
"Two slices of pizza and soda from the deli for $5, great deal"
Jonathan Chambers
Appears on 6 lists
Created by Rebekah Janitz
3 items
Created by Jim L.
12 itemsCreated by Mena Freed
25 items