Mill Creek Tavern
American Restaurant and Pub$$$$
Bayville
Ranked #2 for American restaurants in Bayville
"Stuffed artichoke, seafood pot pie and short ribs were delicious."(2 Tips)
"where I’m having Tijuana Tuesday for dinner"(3 Tips)
8 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- rock and roll
- short ribs
- s'mores
- live music
- great value
- (5 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Steve LeVineSeptember 3, 2012Second time here and again very satisfied. The Lemon Sole Oreganata was moist, flaky and tasty. Mussels cooked perfect and full of flavor. Not inexpensive but worth it. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Donna JaronczykFebruary 5, 2018Stuffed artichoke, seafood pot pie and short ribs were delicious. Service is outstanding.
Jamie ScottOctober 22, 2010Catch the live bands on Friday and Saturday nights! Great Rock and Roll! Food rocks too. Great ratings in Zagats and NY Times.- When I come on a Tuesday, this is where I’m having Tijuana Tuesday for dinner there.
Réal LavigneAugust 22, 2011Try the seafood pot pie. It was amazing, shrimp, lobster, scallops with potatoes, peas and carrots.
Great local place with an exceptional host. Have a great meal and finish it up with the Smores that you make right at your table. Read more
Eric PreteNovember 8, 2015This place blows. Over 3 hours for dinner and food came out reheated and cold. Worst dinner ever!
29 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Long Island's most popular neighborhood restaurants, Mill Creek Tavern serves seasonal robustly flavored, American cuisine in a relaxed setting of casual elegance. We offer a full dinner menu with daily specials in the dining room and the bar...
Closed until 4:30 PM Wednesday (Show more)
- Wed–Thu, Sun
- 4:30 PM–8:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 4:30 PM–8:30 PM
(516) 628-2000
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 7.8
"The casual, seafood eatery delivers a waterfront view along with the delicious sesame-crusted tuna, baked clams, pan-seared diver sea scallops and crabcakes vie with burgers, nachos and quesadillas."
Newsday - 6.9
"Get the stuffed artichoke!"
Kristen Malzone - 7.2
"It's a great spot great bartenders especially Chris his Christopher walken impersonation is worth a great tip the food is excellent fair priced good people best spot in oyster bay"
Scott Kornfeld
Appears on 10 lists
Created by Mary Jasen
4 items
Top 10 restaurants when money is no object
Created by Alyssa Barker
3 items • 2 followers