MilkMade Tasting Room
(Now Closed)Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
35 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
oh! and don't forget to sign up for their Membership service: two great new flavors delivered every month to your home or office. I get it to my office and the team loves it!
Nick GrayJanuary 9, 2016Best value: The tasting flight ($12) includes any 5 flavors in 5 mini-cones. Get this if it is your first time and you want to make a date out of it! All flavors are created here at the studio.
AmateurConciergeAugust 19, 2018Fantastic ice cream hole in the wall! Ambitious flavors! Basil chip was awesome. So was the peach cobbler I had.
Foxxy BOctober 15, 2017Tiny shop. Very interesting & fun variety of flavors, but not over the top. Cool twists on some originals, too. Funky fresh cones (like blue corn maize)!
chinselOctober 28, 2018everything is fresh and homemade here! new flavors every month. the owner is creative and kind! “scoopistas” are ready to serve your favorite flavor!
Super cute and tiny shop! They have a handful of really delicious ice creams, my favorite so far is the PBJ - so good! You can get two flavors for a 'single' scoop- it's the best 'scream in the city. my favorites: chocolate peanut butter, red velvet, sea salt caramel. don't forget to take a magnet on the way out!
- chinselApril 14, 2018salted caramel! anything chocolate based! all of the above. try the interesting seasonal flavors. membership delivers 2 totally new flavors every month !
ShahMay 25, 2019Hands down my favorite ice cream in New York. Honestly love every flavor, but the PB&J in a blue corn cone is really something.
Basil chip — like mint chip but you can pretend it's a healthy salad.
Jen ShinNovember 17, 2015try the ice cream cone flight to try different flavors & the different cones made by the konery!
- Always get the weirdest sounding flavor on the menu. It will be good.
Russell HirschornMarch 29, 2016Cute little shop seen by its pink door frame. Ice cream is SUPER fresh tasting, interesting flavors. Grab a magnet.
Emily WilsonSeptember 16, 2018Gotham basil chip: refreshing, delicious, original. Gets better with each bite!
Alex HennesseyAugust 23, 2015Cobbler Hill is cinnamon base with huge hunks of peach and pie crust. Yum. Must return to try the chocolate peanut butter....
Seasonal ‘screams with weekly variations. I’m a sucker for the cobbler hill and would Kill someone for the key lime pie in the summer. Dead.
Some of the best and most interesting ice creams in the city. Always worth a taste.
Michael SchouMay 29, 2015Great ice cream. Flavors change rapidly, but catch Chinatown Chocolate and their pretzel flavor if you can!
Paul SanwaldAugust 16, 2015I had the finger lakes peanut butter and jelly and it was great. Cool little spot.
Slow Food NYCSeptember 12, 2012Happy to award the Snail of Approval to MilkMade Ice Cream. Follow our #SnailofApproval list here:
Soraya DarabiMay 30, 2015Everything is good here, especially the salted caramel ice cream! Love Milk Made :)
Peter BJune 3, 2015Rockaway Road in a toasted coconut cone is like a little frozen island paradise - take some napkins though, you'll need them.
Brian MasefieldSeptember 1, 2016Sometimes they lack in # of flavors, but Salted Caramel is excellent.
- Asena GurmericAugust 22, 2015I expected their ice cream to be creamier, but the salted caramel flavor was good. My boyfriend had the red velvet with cheesecake blueberry flavor, he didn't think it was so special.
- Michelle LeedsOctober 13, 2018Ice cream is delicious but expensive. The place gets crowded with cranky customers, so it’s not a pleasant experience
88 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
2009-2019 THANK YOU
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Tue–Thu, Sun
- 1:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 1:00 PM–11:00 PM
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 9.2
"best gelato located in the family-friendly neighborhood of park slope. be sure to try their seasonal flavors!"
Lizzy K - 7.8
"Everything is homemade and the people/owners are the nicest. Try before you buy because there are so many good options!"
Elysia Mann - 8.9
"Always get the 3 pint deal. Cookies and Cowfee is great and so is the Chocolate Vanilla Pretzel. Got the feeling it's cash only so they don't get jacked..."
Tony Xerri
Places people like to go after MilkMade Tasting Room
- 9.0
"The biscuits are amazing and the malted milk shakes are yummy!"
Stella Sensel - 9.4
"Bring the kids or enjoy a run or walk in the park. A really great park except for the little shade that is provided in the water lab area"
YanaBelle Wave - 9.3
"Favorite Brisket ever. Great Mac-n-cheese...mmmmmn"
Sam Horine
Appears on 200 lists
Created by Erica Choi
215 items • 11 followers
Created by Slow Food NYC
124 items • 150 followers
