Milk & Cookies
(Now Closed)Bakery and Dessert Shop$$$$
West Village, New York
The experts at Gothamist and The Corcoran Group recommend this place
84 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Celena ChanAugust 8, 2015So many cookie flavors here and open late night! Go for the ice cream sandwich where you can pick your two cookies (I love the salted oatmeal and smores) and ice cream flavor (vanilla!)
Morgan McKeeDecember 11, 2016If the scent of the shop alone doesn't entice you to buy, take one look at the gorgeous, fluffy cookies sitting on the counter. We got a half dozen, go for s'mores and of course fun holiday flavors
Jastine KhoSeptember 29, 2015The ice cream sandwich is huge! You can definitely split it with someone. Personal fave: good ol' chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream
Nadia IssaBellaFebruary 28, 2015Classic milk chocolate cookies in an Ice cream sandwich is what life is all about! Want something even more chocolatey to take home? Do the double choc
Sucharita GaatJuly 28, 2013Tiny dessert shop on an unheard of street. They make cookies and ice cream sandwiches based on your preference in front of your eyes! Get the chocolate monster with dark chocolate. YUM!
honeywhatscooking.comJanuary 29, 2016Favorites here were the Milk Chocolate Caramel - soft and chewy. White Chocolate Macadamia was so delicious. Classic Chocolate Chip was okay!
Village VoiceJune 10, 2013The Bacon Smack combines the trendy and the traditional -- for every bite of pig you'll also find a mouthful of chocolate chunks, maple syrup, dried cranberries and graham cracker pieces.
Ashley ChanMay 10, 2017So many great flavors that you'll face a tough decision choosing one. The s'mores cookie had a cool gooeyness and cracker crunch to each bite, but felt a bit stale. The bacon cookie was pretty good.
Melanie MaddoxJanuary 31, 2018Just standing in the doorway and smelling all those wonderful cookie smells is divine - but so is the chocolate chip oatmeal cookie!
Caroline LeJune 26, 2015I recommend getting a cookie with chocolate chips in it because they are melty bites of deliciousness! overall good cookies, but a bit on the expensive side when they are $2.75 each
Fee ODecember 13, 2015Melt in your mouth cookies. .chocolate chip is a classic, dark chocolate toffee and peppermint snickerdoodle were tasty And moist and crunchy
Danley HuMarch 4, 2017Really lovely staff and cookies are so yummy! The salt caramel chocolate cookie is amazing. Wifi: OYUU pw: 2122431640
The Corcoran GroupJuly 30, 2011You pick your flavor of ice cream and they make the ice cream sandwich in front of your eyes. Or choose your cookie and they bake your cookies while you wait.
Hannah SAugust 30, 2016Cute place on the cutest/quietest Soho side street...Ice cream sandwhiches are a little pricey ($6.80) but huge! A lot of combinations and staff was very nice.
Kyle ByeOctober 23, 2015A few steps from 7th Ave, but sill very hidden. The chocolate chip cookie is delicious! Grab one and walk around the West Village.
Annie LuOctober 21, 2012Everyone here is so nice - came to pick up a cookie cake and use a groupon and ended up screwing up the register with my orders. I felt bad but left with lots of goodies - try the salted oat cookie!
Gloria ChinJuly 24, 2012soft cookies (like chocolate-mint & white chocolate-macadamia nut!) are served warm w/ Il Laboratorio's gelato. ice cream sandwiches are mostly cookie tho
Meaghan DillonMarch 26, 2013Favorite cookies in ny. Must stop by if you're in west village for double chocolate and bacon cookies!
Larisa GrollemondJune 17, 2015Major ice cream sandwiches and amazing cookies, the smell alone makes this place worth a visit.
Ryan BrightSeptember 5, 2015Crazy good ice cream sandwiches. Try the Grasshopper, but consider sharing unless you have time to lose to a food coma.
Phil KatzApril 17, 2016Everything is fresh and delicious, but especially the s'more and toffee cookies.
Alp OzcelikJune 14, 2014Their ice cream sandwiches are the most decadent, delicious thing you can want. They're big, so beware!
ShanellaMay 30, 2013Love this hidden dessert place! The cookies are delicious and the staff is friendly.
Susan J CampbellSeptember 28, 2014Milk chocolate Carmel cookies are deliciously soft and chewy. But I don't think yuo can get a bad cookie here
Helena MJune 19, 2011The classic chocolate chip cookie has rolled oats in it, making it perfectly chewy, and the chocolate chips they use are divine.
Bloomingdale'sAugust 18, 2010Scarcely bigger than a snickerdoodle, this shop lets you design your own cookies from a choice of dough and mix-ins, then have ‘em baked while you wait. Talk about getting fresh.- Kendall ThorntonFebruary 26, 2015Chocolate cream filled cookies are fabulous! Way lighter than you'd expect.
SandiMarch 12, 2012Fantastic! I had the best vanilla cupcake I've ever had - a definite must if you're in the area.
David BanMarch 9, 2014Standard choc chip here is an absolute classic in the genre. Also, if Tracey's working you're in for a treat.
Brittney ONovember 24, 2013Perfect gift for friends and family. They'll love it! Try the s'more cookie.
Arnaud RéautéOctober 16, 2014Good cookies but it's a shame they don't come out warm and melting. Other choices of pastries
Christine BurrowsDecember 23, 2011You can't go wrong with any choice, chocolate peanut butter is worth a try
Kate KMay 21, 2010The Vanilla Cream Filled Chocolate Cookie Sandwich is my new favorite thing in NYC. Move over Magnolia...
Esther N.February 16, 2012Unless you want your hair/coat/everything smelling like bakery, either order in or get it to go. Yummy stuff, just wish it wasnt so bacon-y in there
Ari PaparoMarch 4, 2012Convinced my son there was an actual cow in the back of the store since the milk is so fresh.
257 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Our mission is simple: to take good, freshly baked cookies and nice, cold milk and serve them with love.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Tue–Sun
- 11:00 AM–4:00 PM
- 8:00 PM–2:00 AM
(603) 266-5437
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Jelly donuts are super delicious. Its not too artificially sweet, very fresh and fully filled."
dawn.in.newyork - 9.0
"Great bread, tasty sandwiches, and some standout sweets. Don't miss the pizza bianca."
Serious Eats - 9.3
"Wow!!! Great selection, try the jerusalm sticks, chocolate rogalch or the yummy babka of course"
Dillon I Horowitz
Places people like to go after Milk & Cookies
- 9.5
"The restaurant is two doors down from the main shop on Bleecker. I recommend the Cheesemonger plate to share with friends and pretty much everything on the menu!"
Kathy Matthiesen - 8.6
"Cupcakes are delicious; try the one with banana, carrot cake and pineapple."
Sarper Boz - 8.4
"Great space. Great staff. Great community."
Christian Ely
Appears on 431 lists
New York City's Most Delicious Desserts
Created by The Corcoran Group
20 items • 426 followers
Created by The Corcoran Group
21 items • 78 followers
Created by Gothamist
14 items • 32 followers