Mikey Likes It Ice Cream
(Now Closed)Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
East Village, New York
68 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Funky fresh delicious flavors, many of which sell out throughout the day. Happy, dedicated staff. So happy this place is still around & doing well! Simple yet the best ice cream experience in NYC.
Jess NaldoSeptember 19, 2015Whatever ice cream you choose & just generally do, get it sandwiched between two fresh off the freakin' iron, red velvet waffles. If you don't, you're not doing it right. You're not doing life right.
Staff PicksNovember 25, 2014The SHADYXV ice cream flavor has debuted to commemorate the release of Eminem's new album. It's made with tart cherries, Vernors ginger ale, and hot fudge, all things from his home state of Michigan. Read more
Marc MayerMay 23, 2015This is how ice cream should be. High quality, creative flavors, Hip Hop references and the best waffles I've ever sunk my teeth into. You'll need two friends to hold you back when you want seconds.
Alice HsuJune 29, 2014This place is DELICIOUS! Try southern hospitality and the mint one w/ the brownie pieces! They use real fresh mint, not the green artificial stuff! Great for breakfast, lunch and dinner...and dessert.
Raphael LangenscheidtJuly 16, 2015Waffle sandwiches are huge, chewy and delicious. The ice cream is delicious - go for the chocolate thunder. Oh and amazing staff to help you make your choice.
Aditya BasuSeptember 12, 2014if you want a nice simple cone, with good quality icecream, filled to almost the bottom of the cone, and avoid the razzle dazzle options of places nearby. This is it. Cheap for location.- consistently smells fantastic in the store because they're always making fresh waffles. Nutty Professor ice cream is a must for any peanut butter fans out there
Amy ChenJuly 26, 2016Imaginative ice cream flavors. I got the double strawberry ice cream mixed with cheesecake bits. Small size is a huge proportion.
Mitra SalaselJanuary 8, 2016Waffle sandwiches made to order--their seasonal fruit flavors are all good (like cantaloupe)
Matthew CaldecuttNovember 22, 2015They make their version of a waffle cone fresh and the ice cream makes me think of what Ben & Jerry's must have been like in its earliest days.
Vic C.August 22, 2014The ice cream was a bit freezer burnt...and was described as having cracked pepper corn and balsamic strawberry in it...tasted like regular ole strawberry ice cream to me. Great service
Sonia GrobmanMarch 5, 2015Their flavor of the month is always amazing... Really everything is good and if you can get a pint it is a better deal
Public House WineAugust 19, 2014Awesome ice cream and waffles, and the dudes that run it are great. Get one of their unique Mikey's concoctions for the full experience.
Nick AndlingerFebruary 23, 2015Love the ice cream. Bring some deep fried Oreos from Rays and make a 🔥 Sundae.
Chontieasia CasadoJuly 6, 2022Had their banana pudding flavor some years ago and it was good I’m not sure if it’s still on their menu though
Danielle DavisAugust 7, 2014Jack and Jill homemade waffles made fresh absolutely blew me away -- and fresh mint in IceCream??? Brilliant.
Eric GonzalezAugust 10, 2014Had the Jack and Jill milkshake (practically finished it before I made it back to my apt). Will definitely be back to see what the waffles are all about.
Libby KoberAugust 11, 2015can confidently say the August flavor of the month (black sesame birthday cake with dulce de leche swirl) changed my life
Emily WilsonJune 19, 2016The vanilla is super sweet but super good. It's soft and melts quickly, so eat fast!
Deary HudsonOctober 13, 2015World, try a scoop of the Southern Hospitality with a scoop of the pink Floyd. This place is the best.
Jinnie LOctober 13, 2014killer bee, pretty in pink, and chocolate thunder!!! They are rich and delish!!! :) great service too♥
HashtagNYUAugust 29, 2014Have you ever tried Banana Beard or Killer Bee ice cream? Now’s your chance!
Their business model is so fresh and delicious - for an all time American dessert.
Celine CMarch 13, 2015Chocolate thunder was soft and rich. Love it :) will try some other flavors next time!
Mia S.August 7, 2014Mint condition is made with real mint and tastes amazing. Really you can't go wrong here.
Liang ShiSeptember 8, 2014Rich, creamy, decadent and delicious flavors. And say hi to Mikey. Nice folks in there, all around.
Joey JMay 10, 2015Ice cream was great, but they had very few flavors. Not sure if it was an off night. The Cool Runnings flavor is great.
Cassandra RommelAugust 3, 2015The cool running is excellent. It's not too strong of a coconut flavor but very refreshing.- go for the Mac Daddy (or the Daddy Mac) when you're really in the mood for a treat
- All their flavors it depends on on your individual taste.
Sanem KeceliSeptember 11, 2018You better know what to order when you get there The guy was morose. Didn’t help at all about the menu
Ice Ice Baby is triple vanilla. It's so much vanilla. But it's good.
183 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 2:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Fri
- 2:00 PM–Midnight
- Sat
- Noon–Midnight
- Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(646) 309-2515
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 8.3
"Some vegan ice cream options here as well. My friends like the tequila hot chocolate and the hazelnut coffee the best."
Lacey Nalla - 8.4
"I cant pick a favorite because i like almost everything they have. But i always go for seasalt caramel & apple pie! 😍"
laine.lwk - 8.8
"Taro and Black sesame is the most original and delicious combo you wont't find in the other ice cream shops around!"
Adrien
Appears on 453 lists
New York City's Best Ice Cream Shops
Created by Foursquare Swarm
20 items • 288 followers
200 Black-Owned Restaurants in NYC
Created by Foursquare Swarm
261 items • 69 followers
