NY ITALIAN

1. Gaia Italian Cafe

251 E Houston St (at Norfolk St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Alphabet City · 130 tips and reviews

2. Palma

9.0

28 Cornelia St (btwn Bleecker St & W 4th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 133 tips and reviews

3. Via Carota

9.2

51 Grove St, New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 173 tips and reviews

Manducatis Rustica is one of NY ITALIAN.

4. Manducatis Rustica

8.1

4635 Vernon Blvd (btwn 46th Rd. & 47th Ave.), Queens, NY

Italian Restaurant · Hunters Point · 39 tips and reviews

5. Basta Pasta

7.8

37 W 17th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Union Square · 151 tips and reviews

6. Machiavelli

519 Columbus Ave (at W 85th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 45 tips and reviews

7. Becco

8.0

355 W 46th St (at 9th Ave), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 196 tips and reviews

Carmine's Italian Restaurant is one of NY ITALIAN.

8. Carmine's Italian Restaurant

8.5

2450 Broadway (btwn W 90th & W 91st), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 135 tips and reviews

9. The Meatball Shop

447 Amsterdam Ave (btwn 81st & 82nd Sts), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 90 tips and reviews

10. Locanda Verde

9.0

377 Greenwich St (at N Moore St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Tribeca · 507 tips and reviews

11. Roberta's Pizza

9.2

261 Moore St (at Bogart St), Brooklyn, NY

Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 864 tips and reviews

12. Lilia

9.1

567 Union Ave (at Frost St), Brooklyn, NY

Italian Restaurant · Williamsburg · 190 tips and reviews

13. Osteria Cotta

8.1

513 Columbus Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 175 tips and reviews

14. Piccolo Café

313 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 74th & W 75th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 97 tips and reviews

15. Santina

820 Washington St (btwn Gansevoort & Little W 12th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Meatpacking District · 160 tips and reviews

16. Cotenna

9.1

21 Bedford St (btwn Downing St and 6th Ave), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 239 tips and reviews

17. The Meatball Shop

64 Greenwich Ave (at Perry St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 273 tips and reviews

18. Cibo e Vino

7.5

2418 Broadway (89th street), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 14 tips and reviews

Antique Garage Soho is one of NY ITALIAN.

19. Antique Garage Soho

8.4

41 Mercer St (at Grand St), New York, NY

Mediterranean Restaurant · SoHo · 124 tips and reviews

20. Bettola

412 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 79th & 80th Sts), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 27 tips and reviews

Kesté Pizza & Vino is one of NY ITALIAN.

21. Kesté Pizza & Vino

271 Bleecker St (at Morton St), New York, NY

Pizzeria · West Village · 275 tips and reviews

22. Rubirosa

9.2

235 Mulberry St (btwn Prince & Spring St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · NoLita · 841 tips and reviews

23. Motorino

8.5

349 E 12th St (at 1st Ave), New York, NY

Pizzeria · East Village · 317 tips and reviews

24. Don Antonio

8.9

309 W 50th St (at 8th Avenue), New York, NY

Pizzeria · Hell's Kitchen · 376 tips and reviews

25. Lombardi's Pizza

8.1

32 Spring St (at Mott St), New York, NY

Pizzeria · NoLita · 534 tips and reviews

Vezzo Thin Crust Pizza is one of NY ITALIAN.

26. Vezzo Thin Crust Pizza

8.9

178 Lexington Ave (at E 31st St), New York, NY

Pizzeria · Rose Hill · 273 tips and reviews

27. Celeste

8.3

502 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 124 tips and reviews

La Lanterna di Vittorio is one of NY ITALIAN.

28. La Lanterna di Vittorio

9.0

129 Macdougal St (btwn 3rd & 4th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 184 tips and reviews

29. Zero Otto Nove

9.0

2357 Arthur Ave (at E 186th St), Bronx, NY

Pizzeria · Belmont · 82 tips and reviews

30. Mike's Deli

8.7

2344 Arthur Ave (E 186th St), Bronx, NY

Deli · Belmont · 25 tips and reviews

Full Moon Pizzeria is one of NY ITALIAN.

31. Full Moon Pizzeria

8.7

600 E 187th St (at Arthur Ave.), Bronx, NY

Pizzeria · Belmont · 44 tips and reviews

32. The Meatball Shop

84 Stanton St (btwn Allen & Orchard St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Lower East Side · 621 tips and reviews

Grimaldi's Pizzeria is one of NY ITALIAN.

33. Grimaldi's Pizzeria

7.5

1 Front St (at Cadman Plaza W), Brooklyn, NY

Pizzeria · DUMBO · 590 tips and reviews

34. Bar Pitti

8.1

268 Avenue of the Americas (btwn Bleecker & W Houston St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 205 tips and reviews

35. Extra Virgin

7.9

259 W 4th St (btwn Charles & Perry St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 240 tips and reviews

36. Barbuto

8.4

113 Horatio St (btwn Jane St & 12th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 334 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the City: The roasted chicken is the best chicken in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.

37. L'Apicio

13 E 1st St (btwn Bowery & 2nd Ave), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · East Village · 119 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the City: The parmesan french toast is the best french toast in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.

Numero 28 Pizzeria is one of NY ITALIAN.

38. Numero 28 Pizzeria

8.4

28 Carmine St (at Bleecker St), New York, NY

Pizzeria · West Village · 64 tips and reviews

39. Caffe Storico

170 Central Park W (at 77th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 43 tips and reviews

40. I Sodi

8.7

105 Christopher St (at Bleecker St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 97 tips and reviews

Eater: This tiny, beautifully-designed West Village restaurant serves some of the city's best pastas & a small list of rustic Tuscan-style meat dishes. Make reservations well ahead of time. [Eater 38 Member]