See all
59 photos

Mateys Restaurant

Beach Bar and Seafood Restaurant

Michigan City

Save

Mateys Restaurant

7.5^/10

ratings

"Love these bartenders <3"(3 Tips)

17 Tips and reviews

Filter:

trendy
chowder
prime rib
good for a quick meal
good for groups
casual
good for singles
good for dates
bar
parking
liquor
(6 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

April GregoryOctober 11, 2014
Fun bar. Good beer selection. Skip the Orange cheese nachos get the Hammer Head burger.
Amber Rose AdventuresJune 7, 2016
Rum Punch is verrry sweet. Great experience but better to share at first.
Robyn SmithSeptember 30, 2015
I liked the look and the atmosphere of the place!
Vikki HornakJuly 13, 2013
Love this place and their bucket drinks! Will return next summer!!!!
Jaime MortonApril 18, 2012
Been here 50+ times
Love this place! Best bartenders EVER!! Give them all your money!!!
Katie JonesApril 4, 2012
Awesome deals for 2, during the week- Monday to thursday.
Kristen PattersonOctober 28, 2013
Cajun chowder is perfect on a chilly night.
Joseph LeeApril 14, 2012
Make reservations on buffet night Because it gets packed!
Elaine CooperJuly 15, 2013
Great place to have a good time!!!
Jason SchroederJune 14, 2011
If your on the top deck and someone throws up a high 5, don't be a d*ck and walk by. Enjoy the high 5......
Dylan BuellAugust 11, 2010
The top deck is more expensive but the food and atmosphere is much better.
Elaine LuedtkeApril 17, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Love these bartenders <3
bradleyOctober 16, 2010
Look out! The lobster BLT has jelly in it.
Jessica HarrisAugust 1, 2013
They don't have a lot of pops.
SteveNovember 3, 2011
the friday seafood buffet with prime rib always excellent and summers on the deck work nicely
Dan HernandezJuly 9, 2016
Sorry but this place has the worst service I've ever seen. The waitresses suck and don't ever come around to check on u.....
JayJuly 28, 2012
Smells like smoke and cant go I you're under 21. Don't go if you ask me.