See all
68 photos

Long Island Bagel Cafe

(Now Closed)

Bagel Shop and Café$$$$

Financial District, New York

Save

54 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Jackie S.July 25, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Used to be a regular at the Bellmore location and happy to say this place is just as good except doesn't have the extensive selection of coffee creamers to choose from. Great bagels and flagels!
J DiggitiMarch 22, 2015
Had a delicious everything bagel w/ eggs ,Swiss ..Free (bad) coffee . nice place for a quick breakfast/brunch (take Starbucks coffee with Ya) or take the sandwich to Starbucks
Kosha ShahOctober 15, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Fluffy, delicious and gigantic bagels! Friendly staff! Waited longer for my order and he threw in 6 more bagels extra! ❤️
Kathleen ColishOctober 12, 2013
Very good bagels. Nice addition to the neighborhood. They have a great system - you get a receipt when you order that you bring down to the cashier to check out. Really efficient.
Erin GApril 17, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Efficient and delicious bagel shop, conveniently located in FiDi. Egg everything with scallion cream cheese is my favorite!
Karlsson BanksOctober 20, 2013
The service here is incredible for an unassuming bagel spot. They'll prepare your eggs any style and are a friendly bunch. Bagels made on location.
Cary RaffleOctober 4, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Bagels may not be the first food group that you expect a trainer to recommend, but if you "do the work" you can enjoy the rewards. They're really good here.
Michael SaltzmanFebruary 5, 2013
Been here 10+ times
I grew up on LI and these bagels speak to the same quality. Best in east FiDi. The help is really friendly however the process needs some work.
Luc DoanDecember 15, 2015
Coffee tastes cheap but the bagels are great. I come here to have pre-exam breakfast
Ben GaspariniOctober 30, 2016
Pretty solid bagel spot. Jalapeño cream cheese and egg everything are the tops.
Jacob RosenbergMay 1, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Nice bagels, but can you spare us 6 screens of Fox News Channel spewing insanity? Owner must have an axe to grind with Obama.
MERZMarch 29, 2015
Been here 25+ times
Best throwback music and also a dancing bagel can't really go wrong here
MichelleApril 30, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Fresh, tasty bagels. The manager keeps things running smoothly when he's around. Large seating area & outlets galore :)
tibi taylorDecember 23, 2015
Been here 10+ times
After 3pm, there is a 50% discount! I bought 1/2 pound tuna salad for $3.50.
Sara DavarMay 25, 2013
Fresh baked bagels, good food, great service and cheap and cheerful! What's not to like here?
Tina JainMarch 23, 2013
So many types of spread for bagels here. They also give you XL size to-go containers for your iced coffee.
tibi taylorAugust 11, 2016
Been here 10+ times
This place is now called Brody's Catering. New ownership & new look. Food tastes the same. Prices are a little lower.
Quinton MaJanuary 27, 2013
Pretty great bagels if you don't want to trek down to Leo's. Took 10 min for my bagel so the manager Tim said my next bfast was on him, so I guess I forgive them...?
Kira Garvin LermanSeptember 21, 2016
Been here 25+ times
Now known as Brody's Bagels and while the staff seems the same the bagels are now hard and nowhere near their prior quality levels.
Sandra ChangJuly 4, 2013
Excellent service, excellent bagels. Try the tomato jalapeño cream cheese!
Jacob RosenbergApril 13, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Less chaotic since they moved the registers to the back bit still busy on weekends.
RobespierreJanuary 29, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Very fast service in the morning. Whole wheat everything bagel is on point.
Paul CesariNovember 29, 2014
Egg and sausage sandwich on an everything bagel is on point
Jackie KJanuary 30, 2013
Been here 10+ times
I have tried 3 different bagels and loved them all.
Lindsey NicosiaMarch 2, 2013
Fast service, excellent food. Try the cranberry chicken salad!
Will BSeptember 6, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Best bagels in the city. I grab one on the way to work every morning.
Sara 🌈⚔🍾June 15, 2016
Good bagels and lots of seating.
Jonathan MichelMay 6, 2015
They are very friendly and even remember my name.
ShaunMay 29, 2016
Amazing range of options
John PaterakisApril 21, 2015
The Starbucks of bagel places. They put your name on the order, everything is more expensive than the competition, and the food and coffee are meh.
Cynthia ZMay 30, 2013
Said free wifi on yelp, but couldn't connect. Looks like a good connection but my iPhone just loads a blank page in safari and won't go anywhere.
Carolina MartinezNovember 1, 2015
The bagel is really good
Jacob RosenbergSeptember 14, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Closed - but the smaller place that replaced them seems to be trying to do better at just core bagels. We will see.
Lorena BattagliaApril 2, 2013
Really good pumpernickel bagels and egg sandwiches
Daniel BenettiJune 26, 2014
Been here 10+ times
After 3:30, sandwiches are buy one get one free!
Kira Garvin LermanJune 25, 2015
Been here 25+ times
FYI Their default is toasted
Vito TartagliaOctober 14, 2015
Good bagel, fair salad.
lauren carleyDecember 26, 2014
Bagels are very good
Abby T.August 2, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Long lines in the morning but they move people through pretty fast. Good bagels.
Josh AndersonAugust 12, 2014
This is the slowest bagel place I've ever been to in NYC. Truly dysfunctional. Look 18 minutes to get my bagel!
A FAugust 9, 2014
Inconsistent bagels from day to day. When they're fresh, they're good. When they aren't, they're average.
Annie McGaffiganFebruary 1, 2013
Cleanest NYC bathroom I have ever been in!
Eric KramerMarch 15, 2014
The pickles here are really pathetic. You'd expect more.
Long Island Bagel CafeFebruary 4, 2013
Thanks for all the Kind Words Please tell your friends
Kira Garvin LermanJune 23, 2015
Been here 25+ times
Bagel was good but not my favorite in the area (Leo's) and not worth the rudeness and $$$. ($6 but receipt wasn't itemized so no idea why)
MERZDecember 1, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Legit bacon egg + cheese
Matt LindenbergSeptember 16, 2016
Changed name to Brady's Bagels.
FranciscoAugust 9, 2013
Don't eat the tuna! Tastes like ass. It's like an old-dead fish in your mouth.
Jacob RosenbergMarch 22, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Another service disaster; no smoked sank in, no everything bagels. And of course they took my money before they told me.
Torrey FAugust 22, 2013
Absolutely terrible food with even worse customer service. Do yourself a favor and go to Leo's or Zucker's instead. Seriously, you will regret wasting your time and money here.

1 2

68 Photos

Long Island Bagel Cafe

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Long Island Bagel Cafe

Appears on 40 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.