"the food for breakfast and dinner meals were good and plenty."(3 Tips)
"Great black and white milkshake!"(2 Tips)
"they have the best matzoh ball soup with noodles around."(2 Tips)
"Philly chicken wrap is amazing!"(2 Tips)
14 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- breakfast food
- milkshakes
- great value
- French toast
- good for a quick meal
- (10 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Jamie B.May 13, 2011they have the best matzoh ball soup with noodles around. make sure you get the chicken in it!Upvoted 6 hours ago
Dan CirinoJuly 19, 2015Extra charge for coffee with breakfast...that just goes against LI Dinner culture....what's next? A charge for the mints on the counter?
Matthew SmithApril 18, 2013want here with 6 people 2 didnt eat the server was being rude saying u need to order something or you're going to get charged for $3.. never had that happen i come here alot well not anymore.
Andra MateraNovember 24, 2016Don't go. Nothing was good. Horrible gravy. Gross Monte Kristo sandwiches. We ate about $10 of the $40 we spent. Really bad!
47 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Lighthouse Diner in Wantagh, NY is a classic, old fashioned diner serving up a delicious fine dining experience at diner prices.
Open (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 24 Hours
(516) 826-8111
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.6
"The best place to eat eggs anything here is awesome"
Matty Zip Zip - 7.0
"There's always a free table available. The best diner I've been to. The service is very warm-hearted and the food is just as good. Low prices for a great family dinner!"
Robert Gallo™ - 7.1
"This place has huge portions, great taste and a fun environment of a underwater scene ......Nice staff also :) I am not a huge fan of diners but this place is on my favorite diner list"
Laura Ryan
Places people like to go after Lighthouse Diner
- 7.8
"Love everything about this store....EXCEPT FOR STAR-YUCKS COFFEE!!! LOL!!!"
Dan Cummo - 7.5
"Love this place. Awesome atmosphere. Great staff."
Rick Michiels - 7.3
"The best Long Island bar by a long shot! This is the only bar here with a decent social atmosphere & fun music. the taxi they use is great. Seaford Taxi and Airport Service (www.seafordtaxi.com)"
Larry Khulmann
Appears on 5 lists
Created by Mike Mostransky
41 items • 2 followers
Created by Dale Carbone
85 items • 1 follower