- great value
- cocktails
- meatballs
- potatoes
- grandma slices
- (10 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Village VoiceAugust 15, 2014Casa Calamari is the last of the great focaccerias--originally, stand-up snack shops in Sicily offering a combination of seafood and fresh vegetables in various guises. Read more
- Siobhan McNallyFebruary 9, 2014All the courses fantastic. Shrimp fra diavalo sauce with calamari was the best I ever had. I got three meals with doggie bag. not dying about the TVs all over but food all so good I stopped noticing.
- Village VoiceAugust 15, 2014The broccoli rabe hero--liberally dotted with caramelized garlic--is one of the city's great vegetarian sandwiches. Read more
- Kev SkinnyDecember 8, 2015Well food wasn't awful. When they say prosciutto on the menu they mean chunks of ham though. Also waitress asked us if we wanted shrimp or chicken in pasta. No mention of the 9 xtra $$ each. Clever...
- Matthew HurstDecember 18, 2009Come on a Saturday night if you like to Dance to the Oldies; a house band will be playing music. Order their namesake - it comes in a generous portions, so bring a friend.
- Village VoiceNovember 9, 2010The Village Voice voted this Best Spaghetti and Meatballs in our Best Of New York Poll!
- Rice Balls, Potato Croquets and a Grandma Slice, the BEST!
- Honestly the best calamari I've had in NYC. A must-try if you're in the neighborhood.
- you have to order their vodka pie! it is by far the best you'll ever have!