Lenny & John's Pizza
Pizzeria$$$$
Marine Park, Brooklyn
"Great pizza....best in Brooklyn I'm so happy I live close by"(22 Tips)
"Papa Johns but Afiya"(2 Tips)
"... BY FAR better than dominoes pizza hut and maybe even papa johns! And a..."(2 Tips)
"Chicken parm."(3 Tips)
48 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- good for groups
- casual
- good for a late night
- good for working
- (5 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Joanne CanepaNovember 28, 2017There chicken parm pizza is out of this world! The staff are very friendly. Best pizza in the area!
Afiya ApplewhiteApril 10, 2010This is the bezt pizza in the flatbush area BY FAR better than dominoes pizza hut and maybe even papa johns! And a cheese slice for the cheap price of 1.25 way better than most. I recommend it 100%
Garlic knot special: sauce, mutz, and garlic knots. Simple, yet awesome -- and a full meal for a great price.
BauzenAugust 21, 2010Quintessential slice of Brooklyn Pizza. This is what all those places in Manhattan TRY to produce, while failing miserably: the perfect slice of Pizza.
Ted LevinDecember 29, 2016Been eating there for over 30 years. Food tastes great and is not expensive.
This is the first time I've ever encountered a problem. I order a regular and a pepperoni pie just to get home and find my pepperoni pie is burnt. So carbonized that the bottom is completely black.
Amanda C.August 8, 2014Love coming here for their white rice balls and a chicken or eggplant parm hero.
Angelo BigDaddy AquinoOctober 9, 2012Great food great people that own/work there make everybody feel like family!!!!
Candice James-HubbardNovember 17, 2012Food is excellent, staff was friendly send fast. Love their pizza.
Terrence SingletaryDecember 8, 2011These guy are great!!! They have expanded and renovated the shop. It looks great
Lauren T.January 10, 2013Rice ball special plus a plain rice ball mix it together. Heaven for $3.00 
My favorite pizza for years. People aren't send friendly
Awesome people and awesome pizza. Get there early if you want a seat.
- Best atmosphere in a pizzeria anywhere in Brooklyn !
Annemarie CullenOctober 21, 2011Don't leave without getting a riceball. With a little sauce on the side.
- There is waitress service here! The new dining room is open !!
- Sean WilliamsJune 16, 2013L&J's sucks. Normally I'd be mad at someone for mentioning a real pizzeria in the same category as Pizza hut, Dominos, & Papa Johns but Afiya was dead on. Only thing worse than this are those chains
JanelleDecember 24, 2011Glad to see they renovated, it looks really nice now...but the pizza still stinks. It's still chewy, doughy and NOT crispy. Wtf!
Kat S.December 17, 2010I wish it lived up to the hype -- Mediocre pizza. The crust is too thin; tends to fall apart while you eat it.
Donna AndrewsOctober 22, 2011Pizza is horrible! The cheese is of cheap quality and so is the dough. Many years ago this place was good. I had a few sandwiches and I was sick to my stomach. The meatballs were tasteless and so bad!
48 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Lenny & John's Pizza
2036 Flatbush Ave (between Ave P and Flatlands Ave)
Brooklyn, NY 11234
United States
Brooklyn, NY 11234
United States
Welcome to Lenny and John's Pizzeria and Restaurant where all our dishes are made fresh and with the finest ingredients. Family owned and operated since 1969. We offer a tremendous selection of traditional Italian food, ranging from savory pasta dishes to homemade pizzas. If you're ready to exper...
Open until 11:59 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:59 PM
- Sun
- Noon–11:59 PM
(718) 252-9710
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Lenny & John's Pizza
Appears on 43 lists
Created by Paulie Gee
92 items • 3 followersCreated by Tinkerbells Wand
52 items • 3 followersCreated by Flobo Boyce
5 items • 3 followers
