King's Arms Tavern
American Restaurant$$$$
Historic Williamsburg, Williamsburg
Ranked #3 for American restaurants in Williamsburg
"The peanut soup is to die for!!"(9 Tips)
"Try the game pye it has duck rabbit and deer."(3 Tips)
"Game pie, Rabbit, Venison and duck pot pie Mmmmmm mmmmm good!"(3 Tips)
"... the Peanut soup, the dish of beef, and the peppermint ice cream with..."(2 Tips)
42 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- peanut soup
- game pye
- game pie
- desserts
- dish of beef
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
ChrystieOctober 29, 2014Authentic traditional colonial food and entertainment. Go for 3 course meal, portions are moderate. Peanut soup is delish. Beef tenderloin perfectly cooked. Make reservations. Worth the experience.
MaryJanuary 2, 2014We dined at their special holiday breakfast. The food was delicious. I had the Eggs Benedict and although one egg was soft boiled instead of poached, it was still delish!!
Melissa MassengillMay 4, 2013This place was delish!! We shared a cheesemonger & everyone got something different. My parents sandwiches looked really good, but my Norfolk Pottage Pye was the best!! Service was outstanding too!!
Lawrence CalablasterApril 2, 2017The prices have gone up over my years of visits, but the food is still nice for a tourist trap. I had the chicken pot pie as a young boy on my first trip & I've remembered it fondly ever since.
Avery ChipkaJuly 31, 2015If your eating here for lunch skip the adult menu and order from the kids menu. The prices are more reasonable, and the servings are larger!
Benno KaiserMay 23, 2013Larry the waiter is the best! try the peanut soup, really good! and Mr. Purdy's home brew is really good!!!
Andrew HogueAugust 19, 2013For dessert, don't sleep on the Syllabub. Wine-laced frothed cream, garnished with lemon. Delicious.
- Alejandro Rodriguez MannJanuary 2, 2013The peanut soup was really good! I ordered the game pye and enjoyed it but i would have preffered the meat my mother had!
- Billy OttoAugust 23, 2013Get the Peanut soup, the dish of beef, and the peppermint ice cream with chocolate sauce and a couple of pints of old stitch.
Dana DisboroughNovember 12, 2012Mrs. Votes full course meal is excellent! Each portion was sooooo good -- the peanut soup through the peppermint ice cream!
Shawn AlthouseOctober 15, 2013The cheese plate is overpriced and served cold. The game pie is tasty get the brown nut ale to go with it.
Roy BlancoAugust 11, 2011The lunch menu has the BEST fried chicken. Love it with a nice mug of nut brown ale.
Erik GibertiAugust 1, 2011You'll get a history lesson while your here - definitely worth it. The real tip is to order desert first.
Mikael MerrittAugust 4, 2018Not a place you will want to take toddlers or kids 5 and under because menu isn’t tailored for them.
Hector GuerreroDecember 14, 2013Overrated. They won't take you for dinner if you're a walk-in. They only accept reservations.
146 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Everything is true to the time period at King’s Arms Tavern - all adding to an air of colonial elegance.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–2:00 PM
(855) 240-3278
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Live Music
Dining Options
Bar Service
Parking
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
- 8.0
"They also do Ghost Tours! Highly recommend it!!! You don't have to eat at the restaurant to do the tour."
Rachel Thomason - 7.9
"Turkey Trencher! Also...get a pint of ale!"
Lisa Van Winkle - 8.9
"The fall off the bone ribs were awesome. The literally fell off the bone. You also have to try the sweet potato mash. I will be back."
Isaac Artis
Places people like to go after King's Arms Tavern
- 9.2
"This place is awesome turn back in time. Plenty of history to see and interact with. Great tours. Get your tickets online. Two days would give you enough time to spend quality time."
Mark B - 9.1
"Start your tour of Williamsburg here. Try to get there before 10:30 when they start the "Revolutionary City" with re-enactors outside. Gives glimpse of life in Williamsburg during revolutionary era."
Mark B - 7.1
"The pretzel rolls and brownies are awesome!!!!"
Dawn Evans
Appears on 21 lists
Created by Tanya Emery
30 items • 6 followers
Created by Buford Barnes
23 items • 1 follower
Created by James Davignon
19 items