Grey Lady
Seafood Restaurant, Bar, and American Restaurant$$$$
Lower East Side, New York
"Happy hour $1 oysters 4-7 so worth it"(5 Tips)
"The lobster rolls and fries are both equally to die for."(4 Tips)
"... done filling up on oyster happy hour, check out the bacon wrapped scallops."(2 Tips)
"But selection of Cisco brews on tap is good."(2 Tips)
64 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- oysters
- good for dates
- great value
- bar
- alcohol
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Treats ThreadsApril 1, 2019The happy birthday section prefix section where you share a lobster and 16 oysters with shrimp is killer. Makes you feel better about dropping 80+ with friends. Be split it
- Melissa RosenthalSeptember 22, 2014One of the best oyster places in the city. The staff here clearly cares about their oyster program and takes pride in their selections. Excellent variety as well as small plates. Will be back asap.
Melissa YuSeptember 11, 2016Super rad bartender (I think his name was John?). If you're feelin adventurous, have him whip up a cocktail for you based on your likings. You won't be disappointed. HH oysters $1 on the weekend too.
- Melissa RosenthalNovember 27, 2014One of my favorite oyster bars in the city. After you're done filling up on oyster happy hour, check out the bacon wrapped scallops.
Gary TorielloJune 21, 2015'American Dandy' - Wild Turkey American Honey Bourbon, dark rum, pineapple, coconut, cardamom cream, lime
- Order a Painkiller from Chris or Terrence, tell them I sent you, and they'll give you extra cherries
Nina LoSchiavoJune 21, 2016Try the Peekytoe Crab Toast and just about any batter-fried fish that's on the menu.
DeannaJune 5, 2013This place is like, if Long Island made an actually classy/casual beach bar (opposed to the ones that attempt to imitate that) and then oh yeah, moved it to the LES.
Oysters Rockefeller & the Salt Roasted Beets are the truth.
Julia MontiOctober 20, 2015Wild Saturday night out. Full of yuppies. Good music, weak drinks so stick to beer. I don't think they close till 4am.
Harry William Cyphers IVSeptember 28, 2012The rum pig is a great island reminder of SWR Bars Goombay Smash!
- Amanda KellyFebruary 11, 2015This place makes me want to be on the beach! Check it out yourself! Read more
Kevin LillyAugust 7, 2012The Lobster Roll was unbelievable... Don't eff around... Just order it and thank me later
Maurice FontenotSeptember 15, 2012Beer was $7. With tax it was $7.60. Gave the guy $10. He gave me back $2. Math, anyone?
- Jonathan RobinsonAugust 5, 2012Billed as a Nantucket bar. It ain't. And it's kinda dirty. But selection of Cisco brews on tap is good.
307 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
A taste of Nantucket in the Lower East Side
Open until 5:00 PM, reopens later (Show more)
- Mon
- 6:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Tue–Fri
- Noon–11:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 11:00 AM–5:00 PM
- 6:00 PM–11:00 PM
(646) 580-5239
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Grey Lady
- 7.3
"Beautiful and friendly staff, nice crowd. Visited on a Saturday evening. Beautiful atmosphere and the food was good. Will be back."
Nak Brat - 8.3
"The pork and preserved egg congee + you tiao is amazing! Authentic Chinese food for cheap prices!"
Caroline Deng - 7.0
"Go for dinner instead of drinks. Surprisingly amazing food and great service. Will definitely go back."
Annie Low
Appears on 329 lists
Created by Kino
285 items • 64 followers
Created by Milena Arciszewski
200 items • 152 followers
Created by Daniel L.
12 items • 163 followers
