See all
286 photos

Fishtail by David Burke

(Now Closed)

Seafood Restaurant and American Restaurant$$$$

Upper East Side, New York

Save

Fishtail by David Burke

Has a stamp of approval from The Corcoran Group and New York Habitat

64 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Holly BoundsSeptember 23, 2014
Great food, great service. Sit downstairs-good energy. Request Jessica as your server. Get the Angry Tails appetizer & the taco special. Get a glass of Provocateur wine. Even the patrons are friendly.
Maria TullerFebruary 21, 2015
Smoked pastrami Salmon as appetizer, Scottish Salmon and coconut cream brûlée are excellent! Definitely coming back!
New York HabitatDecember 9, 2011
Either dine downstairs in the casual bar area or upstairs in the more refined dining room/outdoor patio. Any of the lobster dishes are phenomenal but we have a soft spot for the lobster bisque.
Arionna Shannon-DiPietroFebruary 20, 2011
Amazing cocktails, mussels, swordfish, monkfish, tuna, salmon, crab, lobster mac & cheese, and then dessert. Impeccable service. Huge portions. Becoming part of the rotation.
The Corcoran GroupMay 24, 2011
We whole-heartedly recommend the Montauk Lobster Roll - the spiced mayo really gives this Lobster Roll a special kick! And DON’T skip dessert.
Tom M.December 27, 2014
Sit in a booth on lower level and some oysters and fun
Jonathan GoldnerDecember 19, 2010
Been here 5+ times
This place is great. Love the fish tacos and raw bar. Simply grilled fish with one of their delicious sauces is the way to go!
StonehengeNYCDecember 14, 2011
A nice uptown dinner spot with a downtown-ish vibe. Nice place for a girls' night. The fish tacos are good!
Babs HarrisonJuly 7, 2012
Fish tacos! Sushi. Pretzel-crusted crab cake. Branding. The lollipop tree. And Willamette Valley Pinot
Gilt CityMarch 8, 2011
Both avant-garde and approachable, David Burke's take on seafood is nothing short of brilliant. Try the tacos, and don't skip dessert!
JohnnaSeptember 18, 2013
Simply grilled scallops w/lemon caper sauce are perfect, service amazing.
Rent the RunwayApril 26, 2011
This is the one place you must leave some room for a sweet dessert. The cheesecake lollipop tree is waiting!
Sarah SukumaranFebruary 18, 2011
Get the mussels for the first entree on the #nyrw menu. Were great on their own. No need for the sauce it came with! Enjoy
amNewYorkAugust 4, 2014
This burger is only available on the Happy Hour menu. Read more
ChaoDecember 26, 2014
Tuna taco is delicious. Try their happy hour menu.
Lauren FinocchiaroJanuary 30, 2011
Not a seafood eater, but the food here is fabulous. Loved the pretzel crusted crab cake and if course the cheesecake lollipops
JM ValdiviaMay 27, 2014
Try Lobster menu. Delicious. Nice wine selection too.
Irene HsuehAugust 7, 2014
Lobster and seafood are good!
Karlsson's VodkaMay 21, 2012
Try the Swedish Mule cocktail - Karlsson's Gold Vodka with ginger beer, bitters, and lime juice!
Jenny Soo HooOctober 29, 2012
$1 oysters/clams $5 burger $5 sangria/beer during 4-7pm happy hour at the bar/lounge area!
Mariana LSeptember 27, 2012
Love the pretzel-crusted crabcakes. Don't get your teeth stuck in the brittle on your way out.
Amanda KellyFebruary 20, 2015
Great spot!! Check out the virtual tour before you go! Read more
Anthea PenaSeptember 21, 2011
D Burkes, serves good priced entrees in lounge after DR closes. Tuna burger, lobster roll,sm salmon & arugula pizza
Bug EJune 22, 2013
coolest bartender- ever. even sings for you.
Aaron MeierDecember 6, 2010
Their specialty desert: cheesecake lollipops are awesome. I'm not a fan of the bubblegum flavored whipped cream though.
DanwenAugust 26, 2014
Sunday lobster Louie prix fixe. Do it.
Matthew BogardJune 17, 2011
The Fishtail Paella hands down best dish. A great way to sample a variety of proteins.
PaulinaDecember 28, 2014
Oyster shucking here needs work. Lobster dumplings are good.
Jeremy JacobowitzAugust 24, 2014
Food was good, not great. And definitely overpriced. Make sure to grab the free peanut brittle on the way out!
Judy LewisFebruary 10, 2012
The best angry lobster and don't skip dessert!! Amazing!
Emily HuntMarch 7, 2013
Go for dinner.... great toffee at the front hostess stand
The Corcoran GroupMay 3, 2012
Try the Lobster Dumplings - First Course
Jacob SchulmanJanuary 24, 2014
$45 3 course tasting menu is very legit.
Amy CarothersDecember 16, 2011
Unwrapping more holiday deals: New York City Restaurants serving a second helping. http://exm.nr/ryng1B Read more
Chris WagnerMay 18, 2014
Hostess stand is towards the back of the lower level.
Annie KJuly 21, 2010
fish tacos were GREAT! the salmon was ordinary, and the trout almondine was flavorful and yummy.
IsabelFebruary 28, 2014
Cheesecake lollipop tree!
James BaileyJuly 25, 2011
The lobster dumplings are a great presentation and flavor!
Dane AskaFebruary 7, 2015
Everything $$$$
The Corcoran GroupJune 6, 2012
Try the The Burger
Julia HawkinsDecember 18, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Grab a drink at the bar before dinner - the southsider is to die for!
Keenan ReillyApril 5, 2010
Crab cakes and fish tacos are amazing. Don't forget the peanut brittle on the way out.
Rob CalvinSeptember 23, 2012
The salmon tartar is beautiful.
Sara SabetFebruary 1, 2013
I don't think you'll ever have a chance to eat bubblegum whipped cream.
Raul CisternaJuly 15, 2012
Ask for the cheesecake... Terrific!
KamasilAugust 13, 2013
You gotta have the lollipops!!!!!
Amy CarothersDecember 7, 2011
New York City Restaurants are cooking up spirited Christmas Menus http://exm.nr/vSxlTK Read more
Kaity ChanAugust 7, 2014
Could use a bit of better service and flavor in food. Dessert wasnt as expected or as stated in menu.
keeley pattersonDecember 15, 2013
Stuffed my pockets with peanut brittle
Jeremy OngOctober 21, 2012
Try the Petit Fours

1 2

286 Photos

Fishtail by David Burke

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Fishtail by David Burke

Appears on 157 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.