See all
365 photos

Emmy Squared

Pizzeria$$$$

Williamsburg, Brooklyn

Save

Emmy Squared

9.0^/10

906

ratings

Ranked #10 for burgers in Brooklyn
"The Roni Supreme is delicious, but not for those who dislike spice."(19 Tips)
"The okonomi fries are a must in addition to any pizza"(9 Tips)
"Emmy Squared pizza is magnificent & Angel Pie is great as well!"(8 Tips)
"Big Matt burger is simultaneously amazing and challenging."(6 Tips)

167 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
roni supreme
lively
burgers
casual
good for dates
okonomi fries
angel pie
sandwiches
spicy food
good for groups
off-menu items
cheese
great value
rum punch
crowded
good for singles
salads
chili
desserts
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Jeff WooMay 5, 2016
Sure, the 🍕 here is damn good (Roni supreme may be even better than Prince St 😳). But you can't leave without trying the Okonomi Fries w/ Mayo and 'dancing' Bonito! It's brilliant! 💃
Emily WilsonMay 1, 2016
If you like a little spice on your pizza, go for the Roni Supreme. It has "lots of pepperoni" & the calabrian chiles give it a perfect kick.
Jesse LaneJuly 15, 2016
The Okonomi fries with bonito were killer. Didn't get to try the crispy cheddar curds, but I watched enviously as the people at the table next to me devoured them. Will definitely be back for round 2
Nicole FormicaMay 31, 2016
Best pizza in Williamsburg, hands down. Be sure to get the Angel Pie, honestly one of the best pizzas I have ever had. The Margarita is also a great choice.
EaterJuly 6, 2016
The pizzas are baked in pans and resemble Sicilian-style pies. Options include the Deluxe (sauce, mozzarella, sausage, peppers, mushrooms) and the Lou-Wow (sauce, mozzarella, spicy pineapple, ham). Read more
Vanessa HammondsAugust 22, 2016
Big Matt burger + rum punch...visiting from Texas(weLOVEbeef) so I was surprised to fall in love with this burger so much - easily one of the top 3 burgers I've ever had in LIFE! Pizza was a let down
Rubén GarcíaJanuary 28, 2018
Top notch thick crust pizza. Get for sure the Colony, their version of the pepperoni pizza with jalapenos and honey. While still good, I don't recommend the Deluxe, it's nothing that special.
Jenna Odett LaskinNovember 1, 2016
Some of the best 🍕 in the city. Go with a group to try a selection of pies (faves include margarita with fresh burrata, angel pie, roni supreme). Chix sandwich! Burgers are only served downstairs.
Barry BloomSeptember 4, 2016
Out of the way in Willyburg, unexpected great brunch place for 10 set up my son, Raph, who has impeccable taste. Great chicken parm, burger, spicy chicken all on pretzel buns. Signature pizzas. Yum!
Mike WaterhouseOctober 7, 2016
This place offers a NY pizza experience like no other. The deep dish-style crust is baked to perfection w/ a crispy outside & soft center. Each 6-slice pizza serves 1.5 people. Save room for dessert!
Alper BahçekapılıSeptember 20, 2016
One of the best pizza places in NYC. Their Angel Pie is straight from heaven. They're are really good at burgers as well. But they definitely need to work on their playlist. Same songs, everyday.
Adam KubanMay 17, 2016
The pizza is fantastic, but don't sleep on the fabulous chicken Parm sandwich. One of the best in the city!
No Leftovers Jackie GebelJanuary 11, 2017
The #1 best pizza in NYC. It's addicting and you won't be able to leave any bites behind; get the Burger if you can!
Noah WeissJuly 9, 2016
The Detroit style deep dish pizza is quote good (Roni Supreme), but the double stack burger is absurdly good -- top 3 in the city and big enough to share.
Adam RedstoneOctober 21, 2016
As someone who grew up in metro Detroit I can unequivocally state that Emmy^2 has vastly improved on my childhood memories of Buddy's pizza there. The crust is rich but light. Corner slices all day!
Cynthia LinSeptember 4, 2016
The best pizza I've had in a lonnnnng time! The classic burrata and basil was amazing. The crust is thick but fluffy inside and crisp on the edges!
Anna LeeMay 30, 2016
Get the double stack burger with waffle fries or chicken parm sandwich. Both were incredibly delicious, filling, and finger licking good (literally, because they are messy)
Michael 🍷 ElmgreenMay 20, 2017
Been here 5+ times
The pizza here haunts my dreams. The Lou Wow is the best Hawaiian you will every try. Interesting canned beer selection and quartinos of wine from Gotham project. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Eric FrancoAugust 5, 2016
All the "white" sauce less pies are on point. It's also still new & less crowded then the hype storm at Emmy original
Danielle DolginMay 13, 2016
Endless Summer is a simple yet delicious salad and great way to start. I'm sure all the pizzas are incredible, but the truffle Angel Pie is INSANE
Zayed KhanJune 29, 2016
The burger patty is wrapped w/ a potent cheddar, and slathered w/ a lovely thick aoli w/ red peppers. Paired with the dense pretzel bun and juicy patty, the flavours can almost feel overwhelming.
Borys PierovNovember 20, 2017
One of the best burgers I tried in US so far - comparable to Spotted Pig. Okonomi-style fries is a must. Pizza is delicious as well!
IrmaZandl ZandlSlantNovember 7, 2016
The hatchback is my favorite. Super delicious with chiles, chorizo, cream and mozzarella. Very friendly vibe. I am not however a deep dish fan - my preference is for thin crust pizza.
Catlo + AddisonOctober 8, 2022
Can’t beat Detroit pizza + “in your moms car” early 2000’s playlist. Try and get us to stop dancing right now.
Berting ReidSeptember 1, 2016
Definitely the best pizza parlor I have ever been to! Fresh veggies, full and variant toppings with perfect blend of cheese and meat. Nice and warm service from crews, I can’t ask for more!
Noah WeissDecember 29, 2017
Food heaven, health hell: the spicy chicken sandwich, burger, and colony^2 pizza all outrageously delicious
Allie BriskinMay 15, 2016
get there early, but enjoy everything. definitely try the cheese curds, one of the many sandwiches and the roni pizza....or of course, the Emmy.
Ben K.April 22, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Emily does it again! New Detroit-style pizza and great sandwiches in Williamsburg. Try it all.
Kathy LiuJanuary 4, 2018
Some of the soggiest pizza I’ve ever had in NYC. As I was picking up a slice, it started dripping watery sauce. The centers were still soft! I came in with great expectations and left so heart-broken.
LaDawn Penigar-MitchellJanuary 24, 2017
This BK pizzeria is amazing! The pizza is doughy and rich and if you like thicker crust, you'll be in heaven. There will definitely be a wait but service is swift and attentive!
Jeff ForbesFebruary 26, 2017
Been here 5+ times
The best topping combo isn't on the menu: get a Vodka pie w/ Burrata + Basil. One of the best things I've eaten in forever.
Alia Ormut-FleishmanMay 13, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Square deep dish pizza with super fluffy crust. yum. Also, an unexpectedly fun drinks list! Cute vibes. Cute pizza. Go.
Courtney LawsSeptember 30, 2016
This place is just as good as Emily, if not a little bit better since the location is a tad bigger. Emmy Squared pizza is magnificent & Angel Pie is great as well!
Alex PyatetskyJune 27, 2017
Came back for the pizza. Despite how pretty it is, for the price. I'd say it's a pass. It's more of a focaccia. Burger still amazing. Still looking forward to original Emily round pizzas :)
Paul BoothNovember 19, 2016
Have the Big Matt burger- tasty and a little spicy. The vodka pizza is delicious, quite light and bread-like base. Crispy too.
Kate FurmanJuly 18, 2016
Go downstairs and split a pepperoni pizza and the Big Matt burger. The burger is outstanding, double patty, emmy sauce, cheese, pickles on a pretzel bun.
AmateurConciergeAugust 27, 2016
Pizza is indulgent: like the best Pizza Hut pan pizza ever (pepperoni and neopolitan win), spicy chicken sandwich was quite bomb as well. 9.6 is early opening hype tho
Kathryn DSeptember 16, 2016
Maybe some of the best pizza ever. Go with The Emmy and the Angel for vegetarians. Crunchy cheese curds to start are also delicious and fun.
Juho RantaMay 23, 2018
Tried the Roni Supreme pizza and the Big Matt burger, OMG 😱 So good and so unhealthy in the same time! 😍 A huge recommendation to all the burger lovers!
Orestis TsapogasMay 9, 2017
Never had a detroit style pizza before but the one I had here was excellent. Thick and crispy crust. Perfect for someone who loves bread.
Raquelle JessieAugust 8, 2016
just say YES. do the deluxe, the sausage is next level and the crust has a perfect crunch. 1 pie is perf for 2 people if you're moderately hungry.
Emily KaneApril 27, 2016
The Angel Pie is truly heaven-sent. Make sure to leave room for dulce de leche churros for dessert!
Amanda RellaSeptember 27, 2017
Delicious doughy Detroit-style pizza. Downstairs at the burger bar, they sell the burger as well as a few popular pizzas. Upstairs, no burger but many more pizza options.
Chad HornerFebruary 4, 2017
do your best to try as many things as you can! if you want the burger though you'll have to venture to the burger bar downstairs
Andrew WeiserJune 10, 2016
Gotta go with Le Big Matt, the beef is fresh and comes as a double stack with white American cheese, pickles, and lettuce, on a pretzel bun.
Zayed KhanJune 29, 2016
Big Matt burger is simultaneously amazing and challenging. Parts of the pretzel bun are overly salty. The bottom was soggy before I even started. But the patty is succulent and intensely flavourful.
Erin MurphySeptember 23, 2016
OMG. This is one of the best pizza places in NYC. Emily, their other restaurant is also great. Save room for dessert too.
marcy stoneJuly 17, 2017
Best pizza ever!! Had the classic with bacon which has a delectable buttery crisp crust. Flavorful and delicious!!
Cameron GidariMay 30, 2016
The Ronnie Supreme is the best pizza I've ever had. The crispy cheddar curds are also a must.
Julian ModestoJuly 24, 2016
Been here 5+ times
The Emmy Pizza's PERFECT. Serves 2, maybe 3

1 2 3 4

365 Photos

Emmy Squared

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Emmy Squared

Appears on 1,803 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.