38 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Foad TorshiziSeptember 23, 2015This is an excellent pizza place. Love the food, staff, and atmosphere. The only problem is that it has very limited operating hours: 5-10/11pm. Otherwise, it is a must try of Harlem.
Mark BravuraOctober 31, 2015The pizza is good. Very thin crust. A little burnt in spots. The toppings are quite good as is the marinara. 3 Little Pigs is delicious. The girls liked the Meatless. The garlic knots are terrible.
Eugene LubomirDecember 3, 2015Mouthwatering pizza - shame they done deliver through apps. Try it with the added combination of prosciutto, artichoke, caramelized onion and mushrooms. Your welcome.
The Corcoran GroupApril 30, 2012Hands down…the best pizza in the area and you definitely should try the namesake pizza. If you’re a veggie lover, get the meatless pie.
We love this place and John, the owner, is a real good guy. Our favorite toppings are apple smoked bacon and mushrooms. Goes great with a couple of Red Stripe Jamaican beers.
Have been ordering from here since they opened and aside from the ever so rare delivery hiccup, their pizzas are great. Not sure what all the negative comments are about.
Don't believe the tips that say the pizza is soggy. Much has changed since this opened last year. Delicious pizzas, great service, and good (cheap) wine choices.
Lanre AdedokunFebruary 15, 2015Better to eat in than deliver...high quality fresh thin slice pizza best served fresh than in a box!
Louis BruscoFebruary 16, 2012a menu of artisanal and standard pizzas, notable for a crisp-as-a-cracker crust that's good enough to eat on its own, plus pastas and salads.
Liz DellMay 19, 2013Pretty good thin crust pizza and the stuffed mushroom app was awesome. Overall its not a bad deal for the quality.
brandon gilesJune 4, 2011loved it! wanted more not only cause the small was actually small, but because it was tasty! portions were not huge but were actually the healthy option.
Better for take out. The food is acceptable, but the music (southern rock, metal, rockabilly) and the nervous energy of the owner make it hard to enjoy.- Mike MorganNovember 13, 2012Seriously delicious pizza - worth the price, and a "large" is perfect to share for two.
ZakiyahApril 17, 2012The food is great the prices could be a bit lower but overall it was a good experience from service to taste.
Harlem AmbassadorJune 4, 2013As good as the pizzas smell from the street, why is the sauce lacking in seasoning? Ingredients are fresh and service is timely. Seating couldn't be more odd. Where is the rest of the bar? Has benefit
- Sure, its more pricier than the other pizza joints, but you cannot compare the quality.
- If it's still available when you go, ask for the Three Little Pigs pizza. Read more
James HSeptember 24, 2012Pricy, eh? Come to London. You'll pay more for much worse. As for the menu, opt for the eponymous pizza and you won't go far wrong.
T.J. B.July 29, 2011More a review than tip. I think I would enjoy this place more if it wasn't so dark. The food was decent, but I'm not excited about the prices. Wish they would offer a gluten free pizza option.
Stephanie MahanApril 16, 2011Disappointing. If you ARE ordering from here, you need to get a large (the small is like a personal pizza, 4 small slices) and I would ask for it well done. It seems to be soggy in the center.
Matt GrosfeldMay 6, 2012The pizza is good, but extremely overpriced. Good beer bottle selection...terrible service.
44 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Bad Horse Pizza
2224 Frederick Douglass Blvd (at 120th St.)
New York, NY 10026
United States
New York, NY 10026
United States
(212) 749-1258
Features
Reservations
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Absolutely one of the best margarita slice I ever had thank you so much Joseph!! Wish they have one in Brooklyn? Ops sorry"
Edward Kim - 8.9
"Very delicious pizza!!!! Chicago style but not deep dish - Tavern thin crust is their specialty"
Eric Abergel - 9.3
"One of the best pizzas in the village. Usually has a line, but it moves quickly."
Polina Weitz
Appears on 38 lists
Dining in Harlem (cafes, bistros, sandwich shops)
Created by Harlem Ambassador
106 items • 29 followers
Created by Ryan Field
34 items • 13 followers
Created by D
161 items • 213 followers