Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant
Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria$$$$
Freeport
"Try the Buffulo & Bacon Chicken Ranch Slice - Damn great #pizza."(8 Tips)
"You can never go wrong with one of our Chicken Rolls!"(2 Tips)
"Great food and much friendlier staff, especially the owner."(4 Tips)"... delicious Chop Meat, Cheese, and Sauce mixed throughout the Rice Ball."(4 Tips)
25 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- bacon chicken
- delivery
- chicken ranch
- sausage
- (11 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Yvette EvesforeplayJanuary 11, 2015A slice of heavenly pizza. I've tried the Ravioli and lasagna, great food. Costumer service is friendly and courteous whether it's take out or sit down.- Atlantic Pizzeria & RestaurantDecember 9, 2013Have you heard?! Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant has made another delicious creation...Stuffed Garlic Knots! With flavors like Broccoli Rabe, Sun Dried Tomato, Roasted Pepper, Pesto, Nutella, & Cheese
Brenda nickNovember 27, 2013This could be one of the best slice of pizza I ever had.. what place a truly Italian Pizzeria. I haven't seen this type of pizza joint since my old days in Brooklyn.- Albert nickDecember 3, 2013Yummy Yum Yum....... Goody Good Food....... Tonight I had the eggplant parmesan, and let me tell you it was second to none, I don't think I could have done a better job myself.
Michelle nickNovember 13, 2013Great Service, Great food Really enjoyed this place - attentive staff - good location, food tasty and well presented - reasonable prices - would return .- Atlantic Pizzeria & RestaurantSeptember 24, 2014Atlantic Pizzeria has added new additions to our menu! Try one of our NEW Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Rice Balls!
- Atlantic Pizzeria & RestaurantNovember 2, 2013Atlantic Pizzeria's goal is to keep our customers satisfied. By using fresh ingredients and top quality meats and vegetables, we try to deliver the best Calabrian food known to Mom.
- Atlantic Pizzeria & RestaurantSeptember 24, 2014Another Addition to our menu, Frank's Chop Meat Rice Ball! With delicious Chop Meat, Cheese, and Sauce mixed throughout the Rice Ball.
- Baeddan nickNovember 23, 2013i should try Atlantic Pizzeria which was pretty much right across the street.awesome atmosphere. not five, but TEN stars to u Atlantic Pizzeria!
- Atlantic Pizzeria & RestaurantSeptember 24, 2014A new & delicious item added to our display case... Angel Hair Alfredo Balls! Try one today!
- Atlantic Pizzeria & RestaurantSeptember 24, 2014There is nothing like one of our Stuffed Artichokes! If you haven't already tried one, we definitely recommend doing so.
Explore Long IslandFebruary 27, 2013We featured Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant and other stores in our guide for "Great food shops on Long Island!" Read more
KbreezyAugust 25, 2011Absolutely great pizza¡! It's also got the greatest setup for a pizza shop. It's kinda like a great Italian deli- Elaina HealeySeptember 23, 2014Give me Bonbinos any day. Great food and much friendlier staff, especially the owner.
- Atlantic Pizzeria & RestaurantSeptember 24, 2014You can never go wrong with one of our Chicken Rolls!
Alan ChwickAugust 6, 201408/05/2014 - Very saddened event, the owner REFUSED to serve a cup of tap water with a meal for two.Avoid this facility, especially if you are old and in dire NEED of a glass of water.
Laura ElizabethJuly 27, 2014Decent Pizza but RUDE owner with lack of customer care. I do NOT recommend! No customer loyalty!- Elaina HealeySeptember 23, 2014I don't come here often, my cousin grew up in Freeport. If I do come, its only for the meatball parm, the meatballs are tasteless and the people that work behind the counter, not friendly at all.
29 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant
171 Atlantic Ave (Guy Lombardo Ave.)
Freeport, NY 11520
United States
Freeport, NY 11520
United States
Sunday & Tuesday Pizza Night Special from 4 pm on.
Monday & Wednesday Pasta Night Special from 4 pm on.
Closed until 10:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 10:00 AM–10:30 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 10:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:30 PM
(516) 623-5645
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
See More
You might also like
- 6.0
"Stuffed mushrooms and the fan fried shrimps are dishes to die for."
Anindya Chakraborty - 8.0
"Buffalo chicken pizza is good, white slices are very good, try a pepperoni roll on the days they have them. Very good quality overall."
Jason M. - 8.1
"The portions are huge! The lentil soul is amazing. I've also had the spaghetti and meatballs and it was enough for two"
Hollie Sick
Appears on 2 lists
Created by Jo' Wanico (Nikolas)
40 items • 1 follower
Created by Jo' Wanico (Nikolas)
48 items