Archie's Bar and Pizza
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and Bar$$$$
Bushwick, Brooklyn
94 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
This place really exceeded my expectations. Get the 14" pie with fresh garlic. Trust me you wont regret it. Individual slices and the 10" pie look completely different and probably taste different.
Kelsey A.October 13, 2017Best pizza I've had yet in NY. Got the 10" w/sausage, jalapeño, & ricotta. It was more like a deep dish. We also got a side of marinara no problem and a beer+shot for $5 (happy hour goes until 8)!
Vivi MinamiAugust 11, 2016The pizza is delicious, but never order half/half pizzas. It's our second time of half cheese and half chicken pesto and looks how it comes... I think that there is more cheese than chicken pesto.
Natasha SofiaJanuary 18, 2016Best pizza in all brooklyn, it may become a serious addiction. Please try your pizza with feta, spinach & mushrooms.
Mahesh Paolini-SubramanyaNovember 3, 2016It's quite the local joint - most everybody there seems to be from the neighborhood, and know each other. That said, it's a very welcoming place - nice staff, pleasant (if hole-in-the-wall-y) atmosphe
one of my favorite places to go, especially when it’s 3 am on saturday and all i want is a mushroom and garlic pizza 😩
Dan BartonMay 24, 2015Honest to god, maybe my favorite slice in the city. I know it's sacrilege. Fun bartenders, and a decent drink selection. Best spot for blocks around!
Delicious. Had a small hiccup with my order, but the bartender and manager were quick to resolve the issue. Small place, but worth the wait!
Vuk MilanovicOctober 21, 2015Life saver when you're in the area, hungry and it's past midnight. Good pizza (that you yourself compose), nice beer selection and friendly staff.
Super delicious pizza's. When you look at it tells you no don't eat me, but when you bite into it, it screams YES, YES, YES sooo good!- Alex MillerJuly 26, 2015Delicious and nutritious. Not your typical NY pizza fare, but unpretentious and satisfying. The food comes out scorching hot, so beware.
Margaret WolkAugust 7, 2015Great pizza for late nights! Gooey cheese and a crunchy bottom n soft crust that'll still be good for the morning if you forget to put it away...
Best new pizza in the hood! The pizza reminds me of pizza I ate growing up in the Midwest (NOT Chicago) and I'm obsessed!
Nick SteevesMarch 13, 2015Pizza is good, bartenders are friendly, and a coupla craft beers are available for a decent price. I'm sold.
Julian ModestoJuly 12, 2019The pepperoni slice here is reserved for dreams. Also, pick up a slice of key lime pie from Steve's for dessert!
This is EXACTLY what this neighborhood needed. Also, the service is friendly which speaks volumes. Great pizza! Highly recommend !
This is your late night pizza move. They cut the pie in small squares so you can share easily. Try the mushroom or pepperoni.
Headiest late-night grub spot. Meatball sub was crispy and flavorful and essentially put me to bed. Awesome staff!
Will SchollMarch 5, 2016Fun atmosphere and vibe but the claims about the quality of the food are way overblown. Pizza is fine but it's not excellent.
All the pizza is great and love that it is open super late.
Zii HammadMay 26, 2017Pizza was fine, place is small and gets packed, beer was good, wait was on the longer side. Only spot like this in the vicinity, so I'm k with it.
Kathryn DNovember 22, 2019Beyond good pizza. And the eggplant pasta is also an excellent choice for vegetarians.
Erin AlbanoJune 22, 2014It's all good but def make your own pie. The crust is crispy and soft. V V good!
Great late night pizza and beers, unpretentious just the way you want it
Diana OlympiaMarch 6, 2018whatever you do make sure to add GARLIC. outside of that you can't go wrong
Marta AyraJuly 24, 2016As someone said the 14" pizza with garlic, spinach, mushroom and feta is delicious!!! Draft Torpedo IPA
Michelle SApril 21, 2014So glad there is a late night pizza spot open!! Forget the slice, get a 10", it's a better deal.
New England-style pizza done right. Fun late night scene
Open super late and serves New England-style thick crust pizza and grinders.
Best pizza around, with a real nice atmosphere to the place!
Kristen VasanApril 21, 2016Not your typical ny style pizza. The crust is thick but light, like a croissant. Really tasty and doesn't leave you feeling terribly full.
- Great late night pizza joint, fluffy cheesy dough
- Natalie YoungSeptember 19, 2016Pizza is very tasty, but for some reason this place never really sticks out to me.
124 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 11:00 AM–4:00 AM
- Sun
- 11:00 AM–Midnight
(347) 915-2244
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"Everytime we come here the service is great and this place has a cozy atmosphere. Try the Four cheese pizza!"
Chris Kahle - 9.0
"So far it’s the best pizza I’ve had in NYC and I’ve tried many place! Also their homemade lemonade is pretty awesome. Too bad it’s so far away :("
Louis David - 8.9
"Amazing slice shop. Sesame crust on the square slices and the hot honey slices are the highlights."
Colin DuRant
Appears on 334 lists
NYC's Most Popular Places for Late-Night Pizza
Created by Foursquare Swarm
25 items • 50 followers
Williamsburg To-Do (or Return)
Created by Christopherr Connolly
126 items • 181 followers
Created by Jaclyn Urban
58 items • 16 followers