Amish Market Tribeca
Food and Beverage Retail and Grocery Store
Tribeca, New York
"Try the salad bar, the pizza and the brick oven sandwiches!"(8 Tips)
"It's like a small whole foods market"(5 Tips)
"Go for the brick oven sandwiches"(2 Tips)
"Show your student ID for a 10% discount!"(2 Tips)
64 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- sandwiches
- salads
- whole foods
- delis
- coffee
- (11 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Great place for lunch. Sandwiches, pizza, hot buffet, cold buffet, sushi and salads. If u can find something there to eat u r not hungry. Reasonably priced
Jonathan BrandonAugust 4, 2015Try the New Yorker sandwich from the pizza oven area! Roast beef sandwich on a pizza bread roll... Unique and tastes great. Very crowded at lunch...
The Dominican kid that works in the tribeca location is the only reason I go there every morning he is mad cool, polite, and very handsome he makes my day when I see him at the register Julio !
Lunch special: Grilled Chicken with two sides. The chicken may be dry af but who cares if the portion size and the price are right, right? 😏
Sara JordanAugust 11, 2014Huge selection of groceries and made-to-order sandwiches, salads, pizzas, etc. Buffet. Always packed at lunch but moves quick!
Simon RedfernOctober 17, 2016New Yorker sandwich slammed in the pizza oven! Roast beef, onions , cheese and tomatoes 😋
Break up the monotony of Whole Foods with an an ACTUAL deli style sandwich or a killer salad bar. (Which unlike whole foods offers a variety of items that don't all taste the same!)- NadiaOctober 4, 2013Great, fresh, affordable food! Try the salad bar, the pizza and the brick oven sandwiches!
bolandJanuary 12, 2013They have chickpea curry sauce mix by the meat butcher, add chickpeas simmer for 20mins + tomatoes for extra depth
Great salad bar and the deli guys make massive sandwiches for the price. My go-to lunch spot.
They have everything here. You might want to time your visit though, to avoid the morning and lunch crowd.
ESTHERJune 7, 2016The food and pastries were awesome. Great cannoli's that are filled fresh when ordered.
Daily lunch specials. Tuesday is $5.50 quesadillas. Mmm! Try the BBQ chicken!
Love this place! Wish we have one in Pittsburgh. Definitely get my salads from here. They mix everything up for you.
mahammatt babaApril 11, 2013They offer steamed kale as an option for your salad; a fantastic choice!
If getting a salad, mind the dressing. If unchecked, your salad will be swimming in it.
Try to be nice to the checkout ladies - they have a miserable job, dealing with all the FiDi assholes all day long.- The salad and the workers are nice at the register especially julio
- Don't waste any time looking for actual Amish people, you won't find 'em. They're all locked up in the basement slicing the vegetables for your salad.
the price is better at The Amish Market, and whole food is just bigger. Same great food and ambiance
The sandwiches are great but the service is terrible. This is the one place where the customer is never right.
Jason MeloneDecember 22, 2009An upgrade to the common NYC deli but you pay for it. Good selection of organic stuff. Beware the angry protesters outside.. apparently Amish treats their customers better than their employees. Read more
Sal ShortJune 9, 2011Spicy chicken sandwiches are great here, just sometimes they overcharge you on rare occasions.- JP GraceNovember 8, 2013Never been impressed by this place. It always makes me a little sad inside when I go here. Not very clean. Skip the prepared food. Just get packaged food here.
Spicy chicken sandwich is my go-to. Rock it next time you go Amish!
everything I've ever eaten here has been top notch. great coffee and groceries too
- Holy mackerel, their Tuna Royal wrap (w/ provolone) is incredible
147 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Block long store stocked with an array of Gourmet and everyday products. Spectacular Lunch offerings and presentation
Closed until 6:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Tue, Thu–Fri
- 6:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Wed
- 6:00 AM–9:30 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 7:00 AM–9:00 PM
(212) 608-3863
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Visa & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Free
See More
You might also like
- 8.9
"My all-time favourites: Shepherd's Pie, Curry Lamb Pie, Chicken & Leek Pie."
⠀ - 9.0
"This amazing grocery store offers a variety of produce, such as exotic cheeses, smoked salmon and tasty delicatessens!"
New York Habitat - 8.5
"A great selection of healthy food. Got items that you wouldn't find in whole food. Def a good neighborhood shop."
Rachel Inkster
Places people like to go after Amish Market Tribeca
- 9.0
"Honest Tea on sale, 4$5. awesome, especially the Honey Green Tea"
ira Chikva - 9.3
"Both a moving and calming experience. Beautiful use of water. Make sure to get your tickets online in advance -- lots of queuing otherwise"
candace kuss - 9.0
"Tour and 360 views of NYC are amazing! Fun family activity. They stop serving food at 9pm so make a reservation."
Kathy Beck
Appears on 54 lists
Created by Δ Λ Π Τ Σ ࿐
200 items • 15 followers
Created by Scott Gillis
93 items • 25 followers
Created by Jennifer Knode
26 items • 8 followers
