Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Super 46 Sandwiches

Super 46 Sandwiches

Creator Avatar
Created by Ryan Austill • Updated On: August 12, 2013

1. Judge's BBQ & Juice Garden Smoothie Bar

2104 W Michigan St (Michigan St. and Belmont Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
BBQ Joint · Near Westside · 16 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Pulled Pork Sandwich is on the Super 46 Sandwich List

2. Shapiro's Delicatessen

8.7
808 S Meridian St (bt Sycamore & W McCarty Sts), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Downtown Indianapolis · 98 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Reuben is on the Super 46 Sandwiches

3. Bosphorus Istanbul Cafe

8.9
935 S East St (at Buchanan St), Indianapolis, IN
Middle Eastern Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 32 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Falafel is on the Super 46 Sandwiches

4. Workingman's Friend

8.6
234 N Belmont Ave (btw Washington & Michigan), Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Hawthorne · 37 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Double Cheeseburger is on the Super 46 Sandwich List

5. Ghyslain

75 N Main St, Zionsville, IN
Mediterranean Restaurant · 1 tip

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: The Pan Bagnat Nicoise is on the Super 46 Sandwich List

6. Euphoria & Creation Cafe

337 W 11th St (at Downtown Canal, North Basin), Indianapolis, IN
Café · Upper Canal · 49 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Southern Style BBQ is on the Super 46 Sandwich List

7. The Rathskeller

8.6
401 E Michigan St (in Athenaeum Building), Indianapolis, IN
German Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 77 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Fikadelle is on the Super 46 Sandwich List

8. Hoaglin To Go

448 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Café · Downtown Indianapolis · 44 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Take You Back PB&J is on the Super 46 Sandwich

9. Bourbon Street Distillery

361 Indiana Ave (at W Vermont St), Indianapolis, IN
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 81 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Triple Decker BLT is on the Super 46 Sandwich List

10. Papa Roux

8950 E 10th St (at Post Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · Far Eastside · 69 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: Roast Pork Po'Boy is on the Super 46 Sandwiches

11. Harry & Izzy's

9.2
153 S Illinois St (at W Georgia St in Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 109 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The St. Elmo Prime Rib Sandwich is on the Super 46 Sandwiches

12. Tortas Guicho Dominguez y El Cubanito

8.4
641 Virginia Ave (Virginia at College), Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Fletcher Place · 29 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Cubana is on the Super 46 Sandwiches

13. Gerst Haus

9.0
2100 W Franklin St, Evansville, IN
German Restaurant · Evansville West Side · 56 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: The Schweinfilet Sandwich is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

14. Fair Oaks Farms

8.7
856 N 600 E (at Division Rd), Fair Oaks, IN
Farm · 63 tips and reviews

@MrMichaelFarah@MrMichaelFarah: If you are in the area and you don't stop in for a grilled cheese sandwich, there is something fundamentally wrong with you.

15. Schnitzelbank Restaurant

8.3
393 3rd Ave, Jasper, IN
German Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: The Bratwurst is in the championship round of the Super 46 sandwich list.

16. The Streamliner Restaurant

5.8
201 E 9th St, Rochester, IN
Diner · 10 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: The Ultimate Grilled Tenderloin is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

17. Hinkles Sandwich Shop

8.3
204 W Main St, Madison, IN
Burger Joint · 16 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Hinkle's Hamburger is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

18. Nick's Kitchen

7.9
506 N Jefferson St (Washington St), Huntington, IN
American Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: The Original Breaded Pork Tenderloin is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

19. Triple XXX Family Restaurant

8.7
2 N Salisbury St (at State St), West Lafayette, IN
Diner · 85 tips and reviews

Josh V.Josh VanArsdall: Really good place in a college town. I love the Duane Pervis!

20. Farm Bloomington

9.0
108 E Kirkwood Ave (at Walnut), Bloomington, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Bloomington · 59 tips and reviews

Casey P.Casey Plant: The Lugar Burger is the bomb. In spite of its unfortunate name.

21. Opie Taylor's

7.3
110 N Walnut St (at Kirkwood), Bloomington, IN
Sports Bar · 17 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: The Tom Crean and Crimson is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

22. Upland Brewing Company Brew Pub

9.0
350 W 11th St (at Rogers St.), Bloomington, IN
Brewery · 71 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: The Seitan Tenderlon is the on the Super 46 sandwich list.

23. Zaharakos Ice Cream Parlor and Museum

8.5
329 Washington St (3rd Street), Columbus, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 35 tips and reviews

Jason H.Jason Hammond: The Gom Sandwich with cheese is delicious.

24. Gnaw Mart

4947 State Road 46 E, Nashville, IN
Convenience Store · 3 tips and reviews

Trevor B.Trevor Branco: Great tenderloin!

25. Hobnob Corner

7.5
17 W Main St (E Main St), Nashville, IN
Diner · 21 tips and reviews

Lisa T.Lisa Townsend: If the pot roast sandwich Is on the menu it is a must-order. Ask for extra horseradish.

26. The Local Eatery & Pub

8.0
14655 North Gray Rd. (146th), Westfield, IN
Bar · 71 tips and reviews

S Michele K.S Michele Kofski: Just order the cheese steak sandwich!!!

Nickel Plate Bar & Grill is one of Super 46 Sandwiches.

27. Nickel Plate Bar & Grill

8654 E 116th St, Fishers, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Fishers · 38 tips and reviews

28. Bub's Burgers & Ice Cream

8.0
480 N Morton St (at 8th), Bloomington, IN
Burger Joint · Downtown Bloomington · 44 tips and reviews

Tim M.Tim McCool: Not so ugly burger still pretty ugly

The Friendly Tavern is one of Super 46 Sandwiches.

29. The Friendly Tavern

8.8
290 S Main St, Zionsville, IN
Bar · 47 tips and reviews

Aaron S.Aaron Sherrick: Breaded tenderloin is the bomb.

30. Boathouse Grille

8.2
6225 W 56th St (at N High School Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · 32 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Fish Submarine is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

31. Marbles Cafe

6225 W 56th St (at N High School Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · 5 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Chicken Club is on the Super 46 sandwich list

32. Northside Kitchenette

8.7
6513 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Broad Ripple · 16 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Munchie Supreme is on the Super 46 sandwich list

33. Broad Ripple Brew Pub

7.9
842 E 65th St (at Cornell Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Brewery · Broad Ripple · 69 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Veggie Mushroom Burger is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

34. Boogie Burger

1904 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Broad Ripple · 71 tips and reviews

Chris H.Chris Hunt: The deck is great, and the Monster Burger is amazing!!!

35. Plump's Last Shot

7.7
6416 Cornell Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Wine Bar · Broad Ripple · 20 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Tenderloin is on the Super 46 sandwich list.

Original Gyros Joint is one of Super 46 Sandwiches.

36. Original Gyros Joint

823 Broad Ripple Ave (at Carrollton Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
Middle Eastern Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 6 tips and reviews

37. Carniceria Guanajuato

7.9
1269 Oliver Ave (South St), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · West Indianapolis · 9 tips and reviews

Qatadah N.Qatadah Nasaaj: It's actually a Mexican grocery shop, but the little taqueria inside makes the bomb ass burritos! Find it.

38. Taste Café & Marketplace

7.3
5164 N College Ave (at E 52nd St), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Meridian Kessler · 67 tips and reviews

Chad R.Chad Richards: Get the curried chicken salad on a wheat baguette. Tasty

Saigon Restaurant is one of Super 46 Sandwiches.

39. Saigon Restaurant

8.8
4760 W 38th St, Indianapolis, IN
Vietnamese Restaurant · 35 tips and reviews

Neal B.Neal Brown: Best Bahn mi in Indy

40. Cafe Patachou

8.9
4911 N Pennsylvania St (at 49th Street), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Meridian Kessler · 58 tips and reviews

Kristi K.Kristi Krass: Faves of mine: broken egg sandwich w/ bacon, cinnamon toast, & Harmoni white hot chocolate. Some of the best breakfast food ever! Quick service, too.

41. Barking Dog Cafe

115 E 49th St, Indianapolis, IN
Café · Meridian Kessler · 17 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Buddy's Shrimp Roll

42. Mug 'N Bun

8.4
5211 W 10th St (at Allison Av), Speedway, IN
Diner · 83 tips and reviews

Anthony H.Anthony Hammes: tenderloin or a large frosty mug of rootbeer

43. Super Tortas

1002 Main St (at 10th St), Speedway, IN
Mexican Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

David B.David Brunsting: The Super Torta Cubana made the Super 46 Sandwich List

44. Rock-Cola Cafe

8.8
5730 Brookville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Diner · Irvington · 25 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Mile High Club Sandwich

45. Indy's Historic Steer-In

8.5
5130 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN
Diner · Eastside · 56 tips and reviews

Ryan A.Ryan Austill: Meatball Sandwich made the Sweet 16 in the Super 46 sandwich list.

46. Goose The Market

9.4
2503 N Delaware St (at E 25th St), Indianapolis, IN
Gourmet Store · Fall Creek Place · 74 tips and reviews

Kenney M.Kenney Marlatt: The Batali sandwich got a mention in Bon Appetit. Also: They have Mexican Coke in the cooler.