My favorite Montauk, NY spots

1. Montauk Bake Shoppe

8.5

29 Carl Fisher Plz, Montauk, NY

Bakery · 40 tips and reviews

John Doyle: Jelly Croissants are amazing! Lines can get long, but move quickly. Be patient, it is worth the wait!

Harvest on Fort Pond is one of My favorite Montauk, NY spots.

2. Harvest on Fort Pond

8.7

11 S Emery St (S Euclid Ave), Montauk, NY

Mediterranean Restaurant · 65 tips and reviews

Herb's Market is one of My favorite Montauk, NY spots.

3. Herb's Market

7.6

778 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY

Deli · 23 tips and reviews

John Doyle: The fried chicken is great to take along to the beach!

Gosman's Restaurant is one of My favorite Montauk, NY spots.

4. Gosman's Restaurant

8.0

500 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY

Seafood Restaurant · 52 tips and reviews

John Doyle: Great place to have a good seafood meal and walk around the shops afterwards. Be sure to find your way over to Ben & Jerry's for that late night treat!

Anthony's Pancake & Waffle House is one of My favorite Montauk, NY spots.

5. Anthony's Pancake & Waffle House

5.3

710 Main Street (South Embassy), Montauk, NY

Breakfast Spot · 29 tips and reviews