Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Cape May
Cape May Peanut Butter Company is one of Cape May.

1. Cape May Peanut Butter Company

8.8
516 Carpenter Ln (Ocean), Cape May, NJ
Coffee Shop · 17 tips and reviews

2. Cape May Peanut Butter Company

8.8
516 Carpenter Ln (Ocean), Cape May, NJ
Coffee Shop · 17 tips and reviews

John S.John Schoonejongen: Get used to peanut butter as it was meant to be. Not too creamy, like processed store brands, but bursting with flavor. Try the chocolate peanut butter. Really tasty!

3. George's Place

301 Beach Dr (Perry St), North Cape May, NJ
Diner · 35 tips and reviews

TV Food MapsTV Food Maps: Check out George's Place as seen on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives Read more.

4. Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

8.6
310 Washington St, Cape May, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 11 tips and reviews

Stephanie S.Stephanie Smith: Cotton candy ice cream is the best! Cash only though.

5. Coffee Tyme

8.4
315 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ
Café · 11 tips and reviews

Todd A W.Todd A Williams: Best coffee in the area!!

6. The Lobster House

8.5
906 Schellengers Landing Rd, Cape May, NJ
Seafood Restaurant · 153 tips and reviews

Chip F.Chip F: Tip!!! Eat outside on the deck and order your food from the walk up counter. It's the same exact excellent seafood that is served inside the restaurant at half the cost with no server. Worth it.

7. Hotdog Tommy's

8.3
Jackson Street (Beach Ave), Cape May, NJ
Hot Dog Joint · 26 tips and reviews

Bob T.Bob Thomas: Highly recommend the Texas Tommy bad dog

8. Fine Fellows Creamery

8.6
313 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews

Campbell B.Campbell Bird: They have the best ice cream flavor here: Guatemalan Ripple. Get it.

9. Magic Brain Cafe

8.6
31 Perry St (Carpenters Lane), Cape May, NJ
Coffee Shop · 18 tips and reviews

Amanda F.Amanda Fay: Cutest coffee shop in Cape May. Their coffee is amazing, there's rarely a line and they have coconut milk or hemp milk options! (Also their cheddar chive scone and red pepper scallion scones are AMAZE

10. Cape May Olive Oil Company

7.8
324 Carpenter Ln, Cape May, NJ
Gourmet Store · 3 tips and reviews

AlexisAlexis: There are always delicious samples out for tasting.

11. Fralinger's Salt Water Taffy

7.7
324 Washington St, Cape May, NJ
Candy Store · 4 tips and reviews

JoeyJoey: The filled taffy is a must buy

Quincy`s Original Lobster Rolls - Cape May is one of Cape May.

12. Quincy`s Original Lobster Rolls - Cape May

8.0
320 Washington St, Cape May, NJ
Seafood Restaurant · 12 tips and reviews

Nicholas S.Nicholas Stebenne: The cleanest, freshest lobster roll in all of Cape May. I highly recommend it. Take the 50% extra meet. You won't regret it!Exit zero, you ROCK!

13. Sunset Liquors

7.3
106 Sunset Blvd, Cape May, NJ
Liquor Store · 6 tips and reviews

Michael K.Michael Kline: Unbelievable craft beer selection, great wine selection & a fun, helpful staff.

14. Bagel Time Cafe

7.4
727 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ
Bagel Shop · 2 tips and reviews

Jim L.Jim L: Line looks bad, but they move it efficiently. Tasty fresh bagels and great coffee

15. Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

707 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 3 tips and reviews

Bianca N.Bianca Navarro Bowman: Custard + ice is delicious!!

16. Good Earth Organic Eatery

8.3
600 Park Blvd, West Cape May, NJ
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

Liz U.Liz Unruh: Check out their weekly black board, delicious food, for us tree huggers!

17. Congress Hall

8.8
200 Congress St (at Perry St), Cape May, NJ
Hotel · 36 tips and reviews

Kelly F.Kelly Fergusob: A must-do for any Cape May visitor. Grab coffee at Tommy's Folly, then breakfast at the Blue Pig. Finish your night with a cocktail at the Brown Room.

Aloha Smoothie Co. is one of Cape May.

18. Aloha Smoothie Co.

Gurney Street (Ocean Ave), Cape May, NJ
Smoothie Shop · 3 tips and reviews

19. Westside Market

8.6
517 Broadway, West Cape May, NJ
Deli · 7 tips and reviews

Karl B.Karl Baker: Great for breakfast sandwiches; for lunch - cheese steak or Italian. Fries are great. The meat dept is really good I always get my ground beef and New York Strips there.

20. Mayers Tavern

7.4
Cape May, NJ
Dive Bar · 4 tips and reviews

Britt L.Britt L.: Fried scallops. Best in the nation!