See all
446 photos

The Island Fish Company

Bar, Seafood Restaurant, and American Restaurant$$$$

Marathon

Save

8.5^/10

303

ratings

"Have you tried the Macho Chicken Nachos or the Grouper Sandwich?"(9 Tips)
"End the experience with the key lime pie, best I've had in the area."(5 Tips)
"Gotta try the deep fried key lime pie!"(2 Tips)
"... GOOD! Calamari, conch ceviche & fresh blackened fish sandwiches are tasty..."(2 Tips)

86 Tips and reviews

Filter:

seafood
grouper sandwich
scenic views
key lime pie
spicy food
conch fritters
casual
breakfast food
good for dates
good for groups
great value
healthy food
quiet
lunch
bar
dinner
wraps
coconut
brunch food
appetizers
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Joe WinnNovember 8, 2014
A favorite stop to/from Key West. Eat along the water. Nachos, entrees, a drink. Enjoy the redesigned restaurant and bar.
Upvoted Jan 11
Emily PulisMay 31, 2011
You have to have a Key Lime Colada—SO GOOD! Calamari, conch ceviche & fresh blackened fish sandwiches are tasty too. Not in the mood for seafood—try the pecan chicken wrap or the Cajun chicken salad.
Ligia CarriónJune 2, 2013
Their crab cakes are delicious. Shrimp Diane is buttery garlicky awesomeness and big enough to share. End the experience with the key lime pie, best I've had in the area.
Brad HagerJune 23, 2024
Good all around restaurant, large menu w/ lots of options if you don’t like seafood. Great atmosphere but can get very crowded. Water front views Fast friendly service. Drinks 👍 Captain’s Platter 👍
Anechka M.November 5, 2018
Nice waterfront restaurant with lots of space and good service. We tried only coffee and pies but I would come for the entrees as well
Victoria BergMarch 30, 2014
Service is awesome! Smoked fish dip, blackened grouper sandwich, shrimp po'boy, deep fried key lime pie, crab and spinach dip are all must try's!!
Jim HauslerJune 23, 2024
The barbecue shrimp, coconut, shrimp, and fried shrimp, were all fantastic! Keylime colada at sunset for a taste of the keys.
@SoFLBrgOverloadApril 6, 2013
Been here 25+ times
You definitely must try the fried calamari its a must. I love this place breakfast, lunch or dinner always good.
Gidget JacksonJuly 15, 2015
Large Tiki outdoor restaurant on the water. Great for breakfast, lunch or dinner.
Claire LaddJune 23, 2011
Service was excellent. Atmosphere is wonderful! The calamari was so delicious!! We had a blackened grouper sandwich and grilled shrimp taco... Both really good! I would definitely go back.
Lynn HJuly 1, 2016
Great place for cook your own catch. Nice atmosphere. Very accommodating !
Tom AndersonNovember 16, 2012
Nice view and relaxing atmosphere. American fare. Liked the gulf oysters and grilled grouper sandwich I had
Sarah DunnJune 13, 2015
A sight for sore eyes after not passing any restaurants for miles! Great service and food
Sondra CJune 18, 2020
Oysters Moscow and Rockefeller. So good! Sit at the bar and mingle with the locals.
Jens-Peter AxelssonAugust 12, 2017
Try the Sesame seed crusted Ahi Tuna appetizer! Fantastic, wasabi, fresh ginger and dipping sauce.
Bonnie WelchAugust 24, 2017
Crab cake appetizer has the perfect amount of spiciness!
GraemeSeptember 25, 2016
Great view, meals and awesome drinks!
Sondra CJune 10, 2020
One of my fav places in the keys. Always stop here for drinks outside.
Kristi PattonJuly 27, 2014
I only came to drink, but I was highly impressed with the service. All of the staff was happy and motivated to work.
Eve ParadoxMay 22, 2016
The #Mahi #tacos have just the right kick! #lilMissNetwork #lunch #marathonKey
Gong ChengDecember 17, 2023
Most of the food are just so so, but the fried shrimp is fresh and delicious . Maybe the shrimp is caught locally.
Carl RamalloMay 27, 2014
Great times in a casual atmosphere with a nice draft beer, and some good seafood.
Nancy SeligaMarch 30, 2019
Awesome food was fantastic dining on the water
Carl RamalloMay 27, 2014
Great times in a casual atmosphere with a nice draft beer, and some good food.
Matt YesbeckMay 14, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Best Key Lime Pie ever! Not to tart, not to sweet.
Alicia HarphamFebruary 19, 2014
Great chicken nachos! Definitely a great item to share. Even BETTER key lime colada!!!!!
Paula FJune 19, 2021
Shrimp ceviche appetizer is great!
Dawn DorschJuly 9, 2013
Terrific breakfast! Great service! Lovely view! Huevos rancheros were yummy.
Moe DexlerDecember 27, 2016
Best grouper sandwich in town. Just ask them.
Joseph J HillFebruary 15, 2017
Been here 50+ times
Food can be spotty but view and casual area is pleasing. Specials are generally good.
Lindsay OstinMay 29, 2013
The blackened mahi lunch special was the best dish I've ever had in my entire life.
kommercial kingsNovember 10, 2014
Great food. Good service. Garlic shrimp linguine is excellent.
Deb RudyMarch 13, 2016
Seafood dishes and the view
Carl RamalloMay 27, 2014
Great times in a casual atmosphere. Terrific water view.
Tom JApril 27, 2017
The Buffalo shrimp are tasty...and hot!
Erin StagnerApril 25, 2013
The Key Lime Colada is very tasty! Atmosphere very nice and relaxed.
Amy BunnJuly 5, 2013
Shrimp tacos, just okay. Grouper sandwich was better. Pepper vodka Bloody Mary was delish. Great service just a little slow.
Kim MozdzierzNovember 15, 2012
We visited twice during our trip. Great food and service!
@SoFLBrgOverloadFebruary 1, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Have you tried the Macho Chicken Nachos or the Grouper Sandwich? Follow on Twitter @SoFLBrgOverload thanks!
Michèl DeenAugust 10, 2016
Ambiance is great. Nice location by the water. The food is very average and comparatively high priced. Would I go again? No, there are much better places out there.
Jani RodriguezMay 25, 2014
Chicken soup on Sunday.....deliciously tasty and spicy!!!!
Lili RuedaMarch 22, 2024
Good for sunset time
Kirsten BuchananNovember 14, 2021
The grouper was good! Atmosphere better!
Elizabeth BigelowNovember 5, 2012
Excellent customer service and amazing food! Crab cakes are delicious!!
Karen FMarch 26, 2014
Local oysters. Fresh but small. Tuna carpaccio salad perfecto!
Lorena NascimentoSeptember 4, 2014
Food is so good. I don't wanna leave here.
Nanda Alewijnse-van EijkAugust 22, 2016
The view at sunset is fabulous. Food is ok.
Mel DeLanceyNovember 26, 2010
Steamed Sea Food wrap is awesome for something not fried here. Great place to stop for lunch on the way to Key West!
Sarah ElizabethJune 6, 2013
The key lime pie is out of this world!!!
Geoff SullivanJuly 19, 2013
The Grouper sandwich is literally to die for.

1 2

446 Photos

The Island Fish Company

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after The Island Fish Company

Appears on 56 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.