Ranked #9 for pizzerias in Dayton
"Hands down, the BEST NY style pizza in Dayton!"(2 Tips)
"Can't go wrong with slice of sicilian!"(2 Tips)
13 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- good for dates
- good for a quick meal
- good for working
- casual
- (5 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
K DAugust 28, 2012Yum NY-style pizza w/charming screaming owner. Reminds of a tiny place in NYC where my sis&I (tag along) used to stop after her work. Their Neapolitans are the best!!!
Ian MarlinOctober 24, 2011Best pizza in Dayton! My dads from New York and says it tastes authentic. Get some slices of cheese and split a calzone!
Dayton Most MetroSeptember 1, 2011Dayton's best New York style pie that you order by the slice. You can park in the garage for free - just ask for a parking validation.
Robert WardJuly 26, 2016Im still trying to figure out the big hype is about! I went in to give them a try, and my homade has an edge on there pizza.
Aaron G.September 26, 2012WOW! I came here for lunch and the owners are dropping f-bombs about salads. Don't bring the kids and don't order a salad! "I sell f-ing pizza not salads"!- Welcome to CollegeMarch 2, 2011New York pizza at its finest in Dayton, OH! In addition to great pizza the staff and service are fantastic. Can't go wrong with slice of sicilian!
- JC HullJune 14, 2012I agree with some of the other tips. Hands down, the BEST NY style pizza in Dayton!
- Aaron G.September 27, 2012And I paid 8.50 for two slices and a drink plus .75 cent for a refill... So for 10.00 I got two slices and a refill of Pepsi
Before adding all the toppings, get a NY style cheese slice. Sicilian is great too!
Heather RoccoMarch 15, 2010Just a regular slice. With or without toppings. Feels like you in Brooklyn.
11 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 7:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 10:30 AM–7:00 PM
(937) 222-8031
Features
Reservations
No
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Delicious fresh ingredients fit both salads and pizza. Ryan's Inferno is personal favorite. Great servers."
Melissa Gray - 8.4
"Get something unusual! I love the cheeseburger pizza with pickles and catsup-and-mustard sauce. Unique and tasty!"
Kathleen Kollman - 8.8
"The shroom pizza is great, but you can’t go wrong with the wood fired pizza here! Great craft beer selection too"
JT Rusch
Places people like to go after The Flying Pizza
- 9.1
"Gorgeous. A beautiful, intimate theater with exquisite sound. A real gem."
Kristopher Weiss - 8.7
"A beautiful, 1,100-seat venue that's a Gem City gem. Plenty of surface parking nearby makes in and out a breeze."
Kristopher Weiss - 7.9
"Come here for food stands and food trucks at lunchtime on weekdays in the warm months. Music, too!"
Gerry Manacsa
Appears on 10 lists
Created by Erik Rowley
97 items • 1 follower
Created by Ryan King
14 items • 4 followers
Created by ~Tigerbythetail~ *^▁^*
10 items