The Cubbyhole Bar
Gay Bar$$$$
West Village, New York
"Best jukebox ever... Especially if ur with Jules."(11 Tips)
"Best Lezzie bar in all NYC!"(2 Tips)"Lisa, Eric, Geeta, and Ellen are the best"(2 Tips)
"THE Les bar."(2 Tips)
86 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- jukebox
- margaritas
- lezzies
- geeta
- happy hour
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Madeline McDavidSeptember 18, 2016Feels like home! Love the vibe and the kitschy, colorful ceiling decorations in this teeny lesbian bar. Super gay music is a plus, as are the decent prices. Cash only.
Time Out New YorkOctober 31, 2011The best place to hang out with cute lesbians is this aptly named, cozy bar. There’s no attitude here, just lots of paper lanterns and holiday decorations. Strike up a conversation at the jukebox. Read more
One time a lesbian took the Rangers hockey jersey off of her back and let me wear it. That's the hospitality you come to expect at Cubby. Oh, and always order beer (the drinks are cheap but weak).
Julia ColosimoDecember 27, 2017This is what all lesbian bars aspire to be. Always packed with hot women and great music. ;) cash only. 💵
Gay on Sunday afternoons, a lesbian bar pretty much every other day of the week
Tony XerriJune 3, 2014This place is packed with Ranger fans and zero attitude, making it the best lesbot bar I know and trust me, been to a few. $5 Yuenglings all night and a jukebox that hates Mariah Carrey. Awesome!
I love the Cubby, always, but love it even more when the bar buys pizza for everybody! Time for another beer.:)
Sara 🌈⚔🍾December 22, 2014Formerly a lesbian bar but now a mixed crowd. Half price beer, wine, and well at happy hour. Check out the crazy decor on the ceiling!
Jeffrey GiulianiAugust 26, 2017May have to wait in a line, but the crowd is fun and friendly. +1 for the doorman.
Mike LewisJanuary 29, 2012For girls that like girls, you'll fit right in. For everyone else, even better. Expand your horizons and enjoy great conversation. Haven't been to a friendlier place in NYC. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Showtime NetworkJune 3, 2011Favorite gay bar in nyc. Plus it always feel like a party with all the decorations hanging from the ceiling! -Claire, The Real L Word
Wilmer SOctober 19, 2010My first les bar experience. Had a great time here. Space is a little cramped, but we made it work. They really go all out on the decor of the spot, me likes. Great environment.- Aiden KirchnerSeptember 13, 2011A casual neighborhood bar for the ladiesYou'll find the ladies over drinks in this friendly and casual environment. Boys are welcome, but the ladies are the belle of the ball.
The Spark GroupJanuary 28, 2011M- $4 cosmos/ T- $2 Margaritas/ W- $3 Screwdrivers/ Th- $4 Tequila Sunrises/ F- $4 Fuzzy Navels (till 9)/ S- $3 Gimlets (till 9)/Su- $3.50-4 Bloody Marys + Mimosas (till 9) and $2.50 Bud/Miller L
Nasser AlQatamiFebruary 24, 2012If Sappho was alive should would lurk here happily and with pride. Great bar with a lively clientele ready for whatever the jukebox brings.
Brian MasefieldDecember 30, 2011Fun, lively, colorful place with super-friendly peeps and creative drink specials. It's a lesbian bar, not that there's anything wrong with that.
- I have to give a loud shout to the bartender of the evening, Mitch! Fantastic bartender!!!!!
In the winter, stay away from standing by bathrooms or you'll be beneath winter jackets all night long.
Humberto MartinezAugust 17, 2011Lezzies everywhere, great on Sundays here. My first experience here there were two America's Next Top Model contestants hanging around all day.
Michelle MJanuary 13, 2013Just put five bucks into the empty jukebox only to have the bartender take over the music two songs in. Cheers, thanks a lot!
Olivia ArdenAugust 8, 2014$2 Margarita Tuesdays and free pizza on occasion? This might be the happiest place on earth.
Joe DillinghamMay 9, 2011Maybe one of the most fun bars in the city. I've never had anything but an awesome time there.
My absolute favorite bar in NYC!! Always such a great time. The people are wonderful!!
Margarita Tuesdays with $2 margaritas are the best 😊
Tuesday $2 margarita's now stop at midnight...makes sense why I strolled in at 12:30am and it was mad lame.
- Leelee WJanuary 30, 2011OMG I love this place, the ladies and gents are so welcoming and the bartenders are nice...Jukebox be pumping!
something about walking through the door and sarah mclachlan is on the jukebox is so right!
Charlotte BouwmanMarch 13, 2016Lesbians everywhere so brace yourselves (if you're not single, that is)
This is one of my spots! But, its WAY too packed on the weekends.
280 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 4:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 4:00 PM–4:00 AM
- Sat–Sun
- 2:00 PM–4:00 AM
(212) 243-9041
Features
Credit Cards
No
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Live Music
TouchTunes Jukebox
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.5
"We were thrilled to visit this historic place. It's just a cute little dive at this point, but one that I love so much due to it's place in history. Great value for your dollar on drinks!"
Steve K - 7.3
"This is a very cozy spot. Excellent decor and vibe! Be sure to tip the bartenders who serve some awesome drinks!"
Jenn Sith - 7.1
"On just one visit, I loved this place. This is what gay bars should be. I'll be back."
Juan Carrillo
Places people like to go after The Cubbyhole Bar
Appears on 254 lists
Gay Clubs in NYC - RICK PANTERA'S LIST
Created by RICK PANTERA
67 items • 29 followersCreated by Colleen Sullivan
110 items • 25 followers
Created by Time Out New York
52 items • 5,828 followers
