Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.The Carnegie Club
Lounge$$$$
Theater District, New York
"Awesome cigar bar - bring your own sticks and buy two drinks."(35 Tips)
"Tony Bennett or Frank Sinatra!"(2 Tips)
"live jazz band on Fri and Sat."(3 Tips)
"Sazerac is delicious."(2 Tips)
55 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cigars
- frank sinatra
- music
- bar
- good for dates
- (7 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Tim BushnellMay 11, 2017One of my favorite cigar lounges anywhere, a vintage classy feel, wonderful selection of cigars, the life music is crowded but great. Always an enjoyment to spend time here
Upvoted 1 week ago- The only cigar lounge in NYC. Cosy, elegant atmosphere, friendly staff, wide slctn of spirits and non Cuban cigars, live jazz band on Fri and Sat. Smoke your own cigar for a 10 bucks cigar fee.Upvoted Sep 26
Untapped CitiesApril 19, 2016As long as you don’t mind the smell of cigar smoke, the Carnegie Club is a divine place to read. Choose a leather-bound title from its hand-carved 18th-century bookcases. Read more
ℳ𝒶𝓎♍June 30, 2022The Carnegie Club is a vibe! I implore you to swing by and check it out. Great cocktails, live jazz and a wonderful selection of cigars for cigar lovers. This club is an absolute gem- lisaApril 6, 2018Oh love the Carnegie club can get very crowded especially when theres a cigar/whiskey event as they had last nite plenty of seating can bring your own cigars food was ok enjoy the live jazz
SteveFebruary 9, 2015Fantastic on a Saturday night! They have a guy who does a Sinatra show that is on point with a live big band. Get a stogie and a cocktail and enjoy!
Paul RicchiApril 7, 2023Just about everything. However, to enjoy the music on Saturday evening you must be able to tolerate a lot of people who have, apparently, not been schooled in how to behave in public.
Kristine YappJanuary 16, 2012Saturday nights they have Sinatra nights with a live band which is amazing! There are normally two showings. Also it's a cigar bar and my favorite one in the city. There is a dress code.- Nice Club. Not much selection so buy your sticks at Davidoff at Madison and 53rd or Columbus Circle and they waive the cover charge if you show your same-day receipt and buy a drink.
- Paul RicchiApril 7, 2023The bar in the afternoon is great. I avoid it on Saturday evenings. The music is excellent, but the crowd is pretty much a case study in millennial ignorance and proud rudeness. It is unavoidable.
AmateurConciergeJanuary 29, 2016You found one of NYCs only cigar rooms. Grab a scotch and say something worldly
Jamie CahiwatOctober 5, 2012Pricey cigars, but drinks are decently priced & staff is friendly & knowledgeable. You have to spend a set minimum & have to pay if you bring your own. You're here for the atmosphere and experience!
imbookinOctober 27, 2011Let your guests enjoy a fine cigar at one of New York's swankiest and sole remaining cigar bar and cocktail lounge. Located behind Carnegie Hall, it's the perfect location for an event of any size.
The amiable and efficient bartender, Joyul, knows his way around fresh lime juice.
Great place for a quiet drink on an off night like Sunday or Monday. It's quiet and comfy and there's no cover charge.- lisaApril 6, 2018Love the live band with the wonderful voice of the singer makes you feel as if you're listening to Tony Bennett or Frank Sinatra!
JasonNovember 29, 2014For a cigar club, you'll find a cozy and cool environment. Good sazerac and truffle popcorn too.- Eric, who is on duty Mon-Thu, is one of the very best bartenders in Christendom. Good time had by all.
If you're a Cigar smoker & need a place to unwind, THIS is the place! Old school atmosphere. Had a great server by the name of Sierra.
Chrys KoJanuary 2, 2019Cozy atmosphere and best place to enjoy your cigar. Cocktails could be better though- Stephen ColellaSeptember 26Bring ur own cigars and pay the 15 cut charge. I have 2 double chateaus in my room and just paid 30 for same cigar I got for 10 at home
SV Ah MaNovember 10, 2015Fly me to the moon, with a fat Cuban and an old-fashioned, what more do you need..
oh yea, great drinks and great service. prepare to smell smokey and store your clothes in another room when you get home. . . .
- Awesome cigar bar - bring your own sticks and buy two drinks.
Tom JohansmeyerNovember 3, 2010Save some money by buying your cigars at De La Concha. Bring your receipt (for same day purchase) and they'll wave the $10 cutting fee.
Jose CartaApril 25, 2013Saturdays are the Best witj Steven Maglio shows singing Frank Sinatra' s Music
One of the last joints to allow smoking. Revisit the pre-Bloomberg era in NYC!
Louis VuittonMay 2, 2012Spend a NY evening in the 60s with a scotch and cigar in hand. Come on Saturday night for the best Sinatra impersonator this town's ever seen! Reserve the 10:30pm show for a special encore...
260 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 2:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–2:00 AM
(212) 957-9676
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.4
"Excellent reds even for non cigar people and don't forget about the food which is actually quite delicious!"
Julie P - 7.0
"Great cozy bar atop the Library Hotel. Check out the terrace in warmer weather. The Complicated Kindness cocktail 🍹 is nice with scotch and lemon and a wine topper."
Jeffrey Glueck - 7.3
"Go for dinner instead of drinks. Surprisingly amazing food and great service. Will definitely go back."
Annie Low
Places people like to go after The Carnegie Club
- 6.6
"Great staff and drinks. Wonderful mix of people. Make sure you sign up for the mailing list and get a birthday treat. This was my first time there but it is likely to become a regular hangout."
Valary Oleinik - 9.3
"Weill Hall is a smaller, more intimate venue with great acoustics. It was perfect for a piano recital by Hyeyoung Song that I just enjoyed there."
Mike Chung - 8.5
"Spectacular place that you never know it’s day or night. It’s quite crowded all the time but it’s lovely view"
Julio Escoboza
Appears on 214 lists
Created by J. N.
12 items • 10 followers
10 of NYC's Best Bars with Books
Created by Untapped Cities
10 items • 77 followers
Created by Alexandre Chumer
82 items • 19 followers
