The Burger Garage
(Now Closed)Burger Joint and Hot Dog Joint$$$$
Long Island City
Has a stamp of approval from Time Out New York and Serious Eats
63 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Kevin YehJuly 12, 2017Juicy $6 burgers, thick $6 milkshakes. Real quick service with rock n' roll vibes. This is a bright and cheery joint in a dreary area; do yourself a favor and skip the Chipotle a few blocks down.
Lesley SmaleOctober 23, 2016Great burgers, great gluten free menu. Doesn't feel like other gluten free menus and doesn't eat like typical gluten free bread. This place is legit
- Brynn TaylorAugust 16, 2013Tough choice between a Boston Brown Ale or a Gluten-free Coffee & Chocolate flavored shake! The burger with soy-sauce jalapeños, sriracha, and pepper jack cheese will make your taste buds dance!
Matthew CaldecuttAugust 2, 2018What a fantastic spot for lunch. I had less than 30 minutes so I got the single burger with the usual toppings. It reminded me of how good Shake Shack was before it went corporate
Ailie ChangFebruary 22, 2016You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. We always get wings and cheeseburger with fries. I do wish that they were closer so they could deliver faster.
Nate SSeptember 14, 2014Slightly out of the way but these burgers are so so good (on par with Shake Shack and Five Guys). Pairs nicely with a trip to Dutch Kills.
Jason AndersonOctober 17, 2015First time here. Fries were excellent and the Burger was superb! Meat was tender and juicy. I'll definitely be back here again!
Chantae VetriceAugust 18, 2013The veggie burger was probably one of the best I've had anywhere, surprisingly. The staff is very nice & fast! I will definitely be back!
Journo GirlJanuary 3, 2013Pretty good place, like an authentic burger joint :-) with old rock & roll playing, huge helping of fries, great thick, shakes & even a 10% student discount!
Burger WeeklyJanuary 9, 2014
Solid no-nonsense burgers at a fair price. Sometimes a bit overcooked, but usually the patties are juicy, and lettuce, tomatoes, pickles are fresh.
Stéphanie NamDecember 17, 2014Fast, good service and a great burger for the price ($6)! There are also veggie options.
Time Out New YorkJuly 29, 2011Hamburger America filmaker George Motz has called this counter joint one of his favorite NYC newcomers. The star-butcher blend here—a 4oz mix of chuck, brisket & short rib—is a legitimate draw. Read more
Can't go wrong with anything here! Great spot especially since there are so few good places in Court Square
CompassMay 15, 2014The clean-lined burger diner is popular for it’s all-natural angus beef patties, hand-dipped milkshakes, and casual vibe.
RichSeptember 1, 2013Awesome burger. Sweet potato fries are a must. Fried pickles were good and the shakes were stellar!!!!- Guha ArunkumarMay 7, 2019Classic veggie burger is awesome. Cheese fries too. The shakes are the bomb.
- Execution is a little inconsistent. Sometimes the fries are among the best I've had at any fast casual spot, but sometimes they're crazy salty or somewhat soggy.
JenKuduOctober 13, 2013Great milkshakes and malts. Burgers are always good. Sweet potato fries yes, cheese fries no... Not worth the price.
First We FeastAugust 3, 2014Burger Garage has the best $5 cheeseburger in the five boroughs. Read more
Dave LazAugust 9, 2016Counter staff was helpful and humorous and the wedge salad was awesome and very filling!
Serious EatsApril 17, 2013Simple, thin diner-style burgers here, among the best in Long Island City.
- Really good thick milkshakes. Black & white is probably the best of the lot.
Good burgers, fries and milkshakes. Try the BG loaded fries once, they are crazy
- JenKuduApril 3, 2013Really great burgers, all cooked medium unless otherwise specified. Split an order of onion strings too ;)
Shayla N.March 15, 2013Order ahead of time during the lunch time rush. Go for the veggie burger with sriracha & the works.
robinOctober 13, 2013One of the best burgers I have had in a long time. Luckily it's not "too" close to my apt
Nic GMarch 19, 2013ignore what others may say, this plays blows 5 Guys out of the water. I ate here even when I lived in Harlem.
- Fried onion strings are a complete waste, just tiny crumbly bits. Just get the fries.
One of many favorite place to be after a hard day of class. Awesome food too! #TSBCC
amNewYorkOctober 4, 2011Opened by Palm Restaurant owners, this converted industrial garage is now a burger joint.
137 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Welcome to The Burger Garage! Serving the most delicious custom blend burgers, fries, hot dogs, hand dipped premium ice cream shakes, yummy dessert and more.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–7:00 PM
(718) 392-0424
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, BYO
See More
You might also like
- 7.6
"Go with the Mex Burger and don't forget the Tootsie Roll Pop."
Richard Revilla - 7.3
"Went there today. It's really good the burgers are really good, the ideas of the different condiments, the sauces, the bread, the fries etc. really good food. Will go back"
Jose Taveras - 8.7
"Organic bison burger!! yummy! Strawberry milkshake too!"
miss hoe
Places people like to go after The Burger Garage
- 9.1
"Friendly staff with phenomenal drinks. They have a selective bourbon collection that'll make you blush. Get the old fashioned."
Humayun Rashid - 8.7
"Be sure to explore all of the nooks and crannies. This is an amazing space with an incredible amount of things to see and art to explore."
Kris Peterson - 7.9
"Very cool store, hot buffet is amazing for lunch & take out, limited seating"
Hany Youssef
Appears on 212 lists
Created by Julien @opiwann
196 items • 101 followers
Created by Time Out New York
10 items • 2,802 followers
Created by D
178 items • 155 followers