Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
"white cake at Taylor’s is probably the best cake I’ve"(4 Tips)"Best Bakery for a iced angel food cake."(2 Tips)"Everything is so yummy and delicious---I love the doughnut holes!!"(11 Tips)
"Best birthday cakes, cookies and cupcakes in the city for birthdays!"(2 Tips)
23 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cake
- donuts
- cupcakes
- cookies
- brownies
- (12 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Danielle CroyleApril 14, 2022It’s all so yummy and the store has a great atmosphere! They even did my wedding cake and people still to this day rant about Taylor’s having the BEST white cake they’ve ever had!
- Alan HofackerApril 14, 2022The white cake at Taylor’s is probably the best cake I’ve ever had in my whole life. And I’m 52 years old and a big guy, so I’ve had my fair share of cake!
- Sherri HoogeveenApril 20, 2022Everything is so yummy and delicious---I love the doughnut holes!! You cannot eat just one--a couple of dozen is more like it!! The iced angle food cakes are the best for family get togethers!
Jamie KilbornApril 13, 2022So many choices. I never know what I’m getting, I definitely go for the chocolate donut holes but I ALWAYS leave with more. This last time, I left with chocolate petit four eggs so good!- Martha HofackerApril 15, 2022Taylor’s bakery has some of the best sweets, I personally love the white cake and angel food cake! Light and fluffy with sweet, creamy icing! Always a staple for a family gathering/holiday!
The best cakes and cupcakes! The cake is so good and the icing is even better. Full bakery including cookies, candies, and donuts. And try their homemade ice cream.
Jacqueline MalottApril 5, 2022Love the custom cakes and amazing atmosphere at Taylor's!!! I can't wait to go back!!
- Jeffrey MalottApril 4, 2022I've been going there for years! It's one of those things that is habit forming. I especially like their iced brownies! You can't have just one.......no way!
- Greeneyed BeautyApril 25, 2022My favorite treats at Taylor's Bakery are the Brownies with or with out nuts,the Pumpkin pie,and the glazed cake donuts. Yum Yum Yum 😋
- Abby GilbertMarch 31, 2022I personally love Taylor’s Bakery apple filled danishes! They’re definitely my go-to! They’re pretty cheap but awesome quality
Some of the best donuts in Indy. The Danish, Bavarian, and old fashioned are some of our favorites.- Patrick CroyleApril 15, 2022The cakes here are outstanding! Great place for wedding or special event cakes.
- Bill SApril 23, 2022Best Bakery for a iced angel food cake. This bakery has the best service. The white cake is excellent. Try one today!
My favorite: the cinnamon twists...almost dripping with butter!
Try a Bavarian Creme Doughnut. Enjoy the best chocolate icing ever on a doughnut.
The fried Danish is likely the best doughnut on planet Earth. Beware of the addiction!
24 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 6:45 AM Monday (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 6:45 AM–6:00 PM
(317) 251-9575
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Taylor's Bakery
Appears on 10 lists
Created by Shawn Dickensheets
12 items • 1 follower
Created by John Reeves
3 items
Created by Ryan Austill
200 items • 37 followers