We might have to stretch a little way out of Stroudsburg to get this list, but as I'm still new here, I'll list the places people have recommended to me!
112 West 34th Street (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Cosmetics Store · Chelsea · 50 tips and reviews
Cherry Lynn: My favorite Sephora location in Manhattan! They usually have every product here. Everywhere else is unreliable. Don't forget to sign up for the Beauty Insider rewards card!