Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.S&P Oyster Co.
Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Mystic
"The lobster bisque and baked stuffed sole are to die for!"(5 Tips)
"Best chowder I've ever had, great service, didn't break the bank."(9 Tips)"Lobster bisque and lobster roll are great."(5 Tips)
"Great View, the service is excellent and the food amazing"(15 Tips)
74 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- scenic views
- shellfish
- good for dates
- outdoor seating
- happy hour
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
To start the chowder is rich and tasty, the oyster selection is great and for an app I think the shrimp and grits is awesome. For entrees I like the mixed grill and the broiled seafood platter.
Cliff RobinsonNovember 8, 2011Beautiful views of the river and historic Downtown Mystic are accentuated by the fantastic seafood and pasta choices. A perfect spot for romance, family & friends.
MatthewSeptember 1, 2012This place is amazing. The food and view is solid. The staff is amazingly friendly and helpful. If we weren't leaving today we'd be back tomorrow...
Thom CordeiroAugust 19, 2019Great clam chowder and salads! Friendly staff, great for lunch while shopping. Fun to watch the bridge raise up!
Gigi RiveraAugust 25, 2014The California burger is amazing. Grilled Salmon was superb. Must return here.
Janeen WhiteJune 13, 2016I had the pan seared scallop pasta. It was excellent. Any seafood you get here is awesome. And the service is even better.
eric bornemannJuly 24, 2020Food fish house with some nice outdoor seating by the bridge. Can’t beat the location.
Kevin LynnAugust 20, 2014Oysters on the half shell and swordfish. Had the homemade lemonade with gin. Excellent meal!
Mary StankevichSeptember 15, 2014The best view of Mystic river! Delicious food, especially seafood! Grilled fish is yummy!
Erhan ErdoganAugust 2, 2013Artichok dip and chowder is great. Nice bridge and water view. Great place for lunch or happy hour.
Kate PAugust 11, 2014Don't expect to get normal seating if you're planning on getting drinks and apps. Even if it's a Monday at 4pm and there's nearly no one sitting down having dinner.......- S CJuly 31, 2011Great service! Good with kids and the food was very nicely prepared. A bit on the loud side if you're seated inside when it's crowded. Would definitely return when in town.
Nemas NemakondeSeptember 5, 2011My Fav restaurant in Mystic, great menu & lovely atmosphere with outside seating! The wait for a waterside table is a little long 25 - 30 min. Reasonable service $$.
AngyDecember 25, 2011Probably the best view of mystic river. Try to get a table next to the window or sit in the garden when the weather is nice.
Kasey BSeptember 11, 2012If the weather is nice - ask for a table outside!! Great seafood menu, lobster tacos & yellow fin tuna entrees are awesome!!
Fallon BevinoNovember 8, 2015Best service EVER. bisque and chowder are fabulous, as our the entree. Must-go!
Daniel HegemanNovember 28, 2012Blue oysters are terrific at $2.50/per, added clam chowdah and pumpkin ale for a full meal. Great holiday ambiance too!
Great view of the Mystic River. The salmon poke was great.
Lisa PorterAugust 11, 2014The clam chowder was perfect, paired with a cold beer it was the perfect pre dinner stop!
Lisa WOctober 26, 2013Don't get the tarragon lobster add on to the salads - it's way less than advertised 3oz ($14! For add on). The lobster roll is not as good/and not as big portion as the ones at Oyster Club.
Matthew SpectorApril 7, 2014Warm lobster roll with yucca fries absolutely knocks it out of the park.
Hamilton GutierrezJuly 8, 2013Try the roasted vegetable polenta and the white bean seafood chili, it is delish!
- John MoranJanuary 26, 2013Best chowder I've ever had, great service, didn't break the bank. Check it out!
Elena MattasoglioAugust 13, 2010The food is delicious! A must stop in Mystic! Been served by a waitress called Elizabeth.. She's the sweetest girl you could find on Earth.
Ethan TurkeltaubJuly 9, 2014No reservations, but if you have a large group they'll hold a table for you. However, you need to sign an agreement for them to do that.
Michele Kociolek-BurkittAugust 17, 2013Great food, but keep an eye on the host staff; they forgot us and we had to remind them we were still waiting
Bethany BengtsonApril 21, 2011The deep fried poblano pepper is amazing! On Saturday night it gets a little busy. Just go to the bar upstairs.
Jo RausenSeptember 22, 2012Great oysters, but VERY underwhelmed by the lobster roll (warm), esp for the price...
- M KMay 28, 2012Lobster bisque and lobster roll are great. Everything else is kind of gross, dry and over-salted.
- Ronan O'ConnorAugust 7, 2010Blue point is great as for the fish and chips... Wow. Scallops and sweet wasabi... To die for!
Steve PolandJune 27, 2010Bar upstairs. Great goose dirty martini going on right now :) 45min wait but we'd like to sit outside on water and other places cross street aren't.
Christine X.May 23, 2010Much larger portions than expected. Don't be afraid to sit outside the warmers are great
348 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
For tasty South American flair seafood in Stonington, CT, go to S&P Oyster Co. Contact us now at (860) 800-6356, to learn more about our seafood restaurant.
Open until 10:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–9:30 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–10:30 PM
(860) 536-2674
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after S&P Oyster Co.
Appears on 72 lists
Created by Angy
18 items • 8 followers
Created by Mystic Country, Connecticut
62 items • 25 followers