Shelter Island House
Hotel, Bed and Breakfast, and American Restaurant
Shelter Island
The experts at Travel + Leisure and The Corcoran Group recommend this place
"The bartender, Erica, is the best!"(2 Tips)
"Also try a glass of the house Rose!"(2 Tips)
"Nice clean rooms with a small but enjoyable pool"(2 Tips)
"Enjoy a cocktail or glass of wine."(2 Tips)
13 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- erica
- house rose
- outdoor seating
- brunch food
- private baths
- (4 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- The Corcoran GroupMarch 14, 2011Charming Inn has 8 rooms with private baths, indoor and outdoor dining featuring French/Mediterranean cuisine. Walk to Crescent Beach or to “Goat Hill” for golf. Enjoy a cocktail or glass of wine.
This place is great. Go there for drinks, dinner, apps (get the cheese/meat plate) and sit out on the porch or indoors by the fire. Beautiful setting. Awesome service.- Lot18April 13, 2012Get ready for a little piece of Provence in New York. Fabulous Inn & restaurant. Be sure to try their house Rosé made by Mattebella Vineyards. The bartender, Erica, is the best!
Travel + LeisureJune 14, 2012Named after a hotel in St.-Tropez, La Maison Blanche channels the south of France: pétanque courts, a Gallic brasserie, and an authentic boulangerie.
graceygooAugust 26, 2023Opt for the king rooms on the 2nd fl because the queen rooms are tiny, barely any room to walk around it and no desk and ground fl is noisy w hotel guests being able to look into your windows
Kayleigh HarringtonAugust 16, 2016Enjoyed lunch and a drink at the pool. Perfect summer oasis on a hot day in Shelter Island.
Juston PayneMay 8, 2012Croissant is buttery, flaky, and delicious. It's also popular on this island so arrive early before the day's batch is devoured.
Tom MaximSeptember 9, 2014Walking distance to the beach. Clean pool. New modern remodeled rooms in a bed and breakfast type setting.
David StewardJuly 17, 2011Best croissants on Shelter Island. Stop by for a delicious croissant with jam and butter on the expansive verandah and read the Times Digest.- Mindy JoyceApril 1, 2012Love the scallops! Also try a glass of the house Rose! Made by Mattebella Vineyards on the Nth Fork @Lot18
Hotel TonightOctober 25, 2011Between the in-house mixologist and on-property bakery, this is the place to indulge.
Michelle AJuly 24, 2011Love this place! Absolutely adorable! Bartender Erica is amazing! Tip her very well!!!
36 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
A new brand of hospitality on Shelter Island | Experience casual sophistication and explore the surrounding region from one of 11 luxurious rooms
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 7:00 AM–10:00 PM
(631) 749-1633
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
- 7.9
"Newly renovated. Fabulous! Beach chic with rustic charm. The rooms are clean and well appointed. Service is great - staff goes above and beyond! Try the complementary signature seasonal breakfast."
Lindsay C
- 7.9
"Fantastic fresh local seafood and wine from local vineyards. Dining on the front deck overlooking and water at sunset. It's a must do when visiting Shelter Island."
Craig Strulovitz - 7.5
"Mussels ala Plancha are phenomenal !!"
Mateen
Appears on 20 lists
Created by Erica Virtue
32 items
Created by Byron Brewer
11 items • 4 followers