Serious Eats: Butter-crusted pies with fillings that are more hipster than Great Plains Grandma in style and substance. We adore their chocolate oatmeal pie, plus anything double-crusted with apple or rhubarb.
1652 2nd Ave (btwn E 85th & E 86th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Yorkville · 361 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: You can't go wrong with a chocolate pecan pie; a fine, fine apple pie; or in the fall, an excellent harvest pie, filled with apples, pears, walnuts, and a hit of ginger.
New American Restaurant · SoHo · 457 tips and reviews
Serious Eats: The Dutch is a restaurant, not a bakery, but the pies are just too good not to mention. The crusts are flaky and beautifully bronzed; the rhubarb-rosewater was the perfect blend of sweet and tart