"Peanut butter crunch is amazing!!!"(3 Tips)
"Try the cookies & cream 👍"(2 Tips)
"great frozen yogurt."(3 Tips)"Black bottom pie or blueberry flavors or the sorbets"(2 Tips)
45 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- ice cream
- peanut butter crunch
- cookies
- good service
- birthday cakes
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
CompassApril 24, 2014Founded in Staten Island in 1922, Sedutto has been an NYC ice cream staple. Its Upper East Side location attracts patrons looking for the best ice cream in the city and a chance to wax nostalgic.- Tara DrakeMarch 13, 2014LOVE this place. Everyone who works there is so friendly and the ice cream is so outrageously yummy plus they have great frozen yogurt. They also do seasonal flavors: eggnog, pumpkin pie etc.
Jereme BivinsSeptember 25, 2016Try the bourbon chocolate with salted caramel. The consistency is more like mousse and the bourbon flavor is subtle, but a nice addition to the chocolate.
Go Find AliceOctober 12, 2017Serves hard served yogurt??! Tastes like ice cream and delicious! Try the peanut butter chocolate chip flavor!
Russell HirschornOctober 3, 2015Great mom and pop ice cream with sooooo many flavors. Always hard to choose.
laine.lwkDecember 21, 2014I cant pick a favorite because i like almost everything they have. But i always go for seasalt caramel & apple pie! 😍
Fantastic ice cream and great flavor selection. Try the salted caramel or mint chip.
Jon hoffmanAugust 14, 2014If you like chocolate and mint you should consider a scoop of ice cream that combines the two
Monica CullenMay 13, 2015On a summer's night go get a cone and head to the east river for a nice stroll.- MaryamMay 29, 2012Try Black bottom pie or blueberry flavors or the sorbets, perfect respite for hot summers
Steve MayboMay 13, 2012Great cream. But watch out as they seem to make up prices. Add it up yourself to be sure.
Pumpkin ice cream. The other flavors are figments of your diseased imagination.
Best ice cream in NY. But we want chocolate chocolate chip back!
chocolate chip cookie dough is awesome. or mint chip. mmmm.
Skip dessert at your UES dinner and instead get a giant waffle cone at Sedutto.
99 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until Noon (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
(212) 879-9557
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 8.4
"Super tasty! Eurotart with peanuts, yogurt chips, coconut, honey, and caramel."
Shannon * - 7.9
"What a great addition to the neighborhood! I grew up enjoying Ralph’s on Long Island. So nice to be able to get it so close by!"
Paige C - 8.6
"Great exotic ice cream flavors! Don't bother with the usual flavors, get the mango, coconut or lychee!"
Nick Yee
Places people like to go after Sedutto
- 8.8
"Everything fresh, great quality food, helpful staff, pre made items to help with your meal prep."
Lisa F - 8.7
"Great beers on tap, spacious and friendly staff. Chill spot for weeknight or Sunday beers."
Ranu Rajkarnikar - 9.5
"Beautiful place and views! Great place to have lunch or just get out of the city, while your still in it."
Momentous Promotions
Appears on 128 lists
Guide to New York's Must Visit Spots
Created by Erika A
31 items • 6 followersCreated by Christa Hoegler
135 items • 20 followers
