Schmagel's Bagels
Bagel Shop, Sandwich Spot, and Breakfast Spot$$$$
Historic St Augustine, FL, St. Augustine
"Lox and cream cheese is very good and very popular here."(3 Tips)
"5 dollar minimum on debit/credit card orders"(2 Tips)"The bagel sandwiches are great."(2 Tips)
"Breakfast burrito is awesome!"(3 Tips)
38 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- bagels
- breakfast food
- paninis
- casual
- sandwiches
- (14 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Bardia K.September 11, 2015Lox and cream cheese is very good and very popular here. I also enjoyed the Sunset Strip (though avoid if you dislike garlic). The earlier you come, the better bagel selection. They run out quickly.
Jens LöberMay 6, 2018Very good bagels and paninis. We had the Mediterranean, very fresh and good spiced, and the philly. Tender Roastbeef with melted cheese, yummy!
Tony MNovember 30, 2014We wanted a quick & delicious breakfast, and this place did not disappoint! The ham, cheese & egg on a salt bagel was so good. Great service as well!
My favorite is the Lox and Cream cheese, SO good! Everything is pretty cheap, but there's a 5 dollar minimum on credit/debit cards. ALSO drink discounts for Flagler College students!
Jacob TMarch 30, 2013Has a cool college-feel. Prices are great, bagels even better. Outdoor seating is refreshing in the morning. Try the flavored cream cheeses!- Abbey FuhrerSeptember 2, 2013So yummy and delicious but beware they have a 5 dollar minimum on debit/credit card orders so make sure you bring cash if you want to spend less than 5 dollars!
Bradford RileyJuly 22, 2016Super cute store, not the best service. Food is excellent. Great variety of fruity/meaty breakfast tastes.
Schmagel's is fantastic. Try the jalapeño cheese bagel with veggie cream cheese. The coffee is so good, it doesn't need cream or sugar.
CurieMarch 4, 2013First time here and cashier wasn't very helpful but ended up getting the lox on a plain bagel and the spread is delicious.
Jennifer MatthewsDecember 31, 2014Bagels with lox and cream cheese! So close to jersey style, made my heart happy and my belly fat kid happy!
One of my favourite places to eat in town. Owner and employees are amazing people! I haven't had something I don't like.
Jon DarveauJune 15, 2013Best get here early, at 11:00 all that was left was garlic bagels...unpleasant.
Schmagel's BagelsFebruary 11, 2013Chocolate, Chocolate and Peanut Butter Chips Cream Cheese. February "Flavor of the Month".
Amber HMarch 6, 2012The panini flatbreads are delicious! Best lunch if you want to fill up without spending too much. :-)
What you are looking for is Schmagel's Bagels. They have the best bagels in St Augustine.
CHEDDAR JALAPEÑO BAGEL WITH JALAPEÑO CREAM CHEESE IF YOU'RE A TRUE SCHMAGEL FAN
- The Flavor of the Month is wonderful "Chocolate, Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese"!!!!
The breakfast burrito is the shit. This place has great food and even better service.
- You can follow Schmagel's Bagels on facebook, take a look. Read more
Jeremy MooreOctober 24, 2015This place is not any good for getting bagels, just a regular sandwich shop. Limited selection & they won't sell you more than six at a time.
Ginger and TorstenJuly 26, 2023Nothing bad on the menu. But get there early, they sell out every day
- Go to Schmagels May 3rd buy a breakfast burrito and get a free fountain drink or coffee.
51 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Locally owned & operated, St. Augustine tradition enjoyed by tourists & locals for 25 years we features 15 varieties of NY Style bagels baked daily.
Open until 3:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 7:00 AM–3:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 8:00 AM–2:00 PM
(904) 824-4444
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Visa & Discover)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
No
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast
See More
You might also like
Appears on 32 lists
Created by Alison Heffner
20 items • 5 followersCreated by Jessica Smith
97 items • 9 followers
Created by Sean W.
154 items • 3 followers